Player X v Player Y

[Gambino]

JOM -> Murphy

Or

JOM -> Swallow and pocket $230k.

Swallow with an 88 & 117 in his rolling average now...

Bummmmmp

I'm going with Swallow. The $200k he will make will be more valuable in the long run

[GoLions]

JOM -> Murphy

Or

JOM -> Swallow and pocket $230k.

Swallow with an 88 & 117 in his rolling average now...

Bummmmmp

I'm going with Swallow. The $200k he will make will be more valuable in the long run

With Murphy now, at his price he has to be a keeper. Swallow looks like making more money from this point onwards one would think. I dunno if Murphy can go 110+ from now on, but so far is looking like a top 10 mid. Swallow with the early bye puts me off a little bit, already missed round 1, and had hamstring soreness late in the game on the weekend I believe.

[Woppa15]

Gawn > ???

Tossing up Grundy and Stef Martin.

Haven't seen any Brisbane games, has Archie Smith been playing?

Other option is down to Witts and have $316k in the bank. Although no one ready to upgrade so would be sitting in the bank for a while.....

[Ringo]

Archie Smith has been playing NEAFL Woppa and Stef has been sole ruck. Schache and Andrews have pinch hit in ruck. And to confuse the issue McInerney has been playing better than Smith in NEAFL.

[crowls]

Archie Smith has been playing NEAFL Woppa and Stef has been sole ruck. Schache and Andrews have pinch hit in ruck. And to confuse the issue McInerney has been playing better than Smith in NEAFL.

That has to be a good thing ringo.    Last thing Martin owners need is Smith coming back in to the firsts.

[Woppa15]

Archie Smith has been playing NEAFL Woppa and Stef has been sole ruck. Schache and Andrews have pinch hit in ruck. And to confuse the issue McInerney has been playing better than Smith in NEAFL.

Cheers Ringo. Sounds promising. May just sway me towards stef. That plus he has a higher ceiling than Grundy.

[HoleMeal]

OK here's one...

Assuming Pickett get's dropped along with Eddy...

Which one get's traded out?? (both in my fwd line)

[Hawka]

OK here's one...

Assuming Pickett get's dropped along with Eddy...

Which one get's traded out?? (both in my fwd line)

Pickett better JS (even if dropped) and Eddy has higher scoring potential but probs finds it harder to get back into the team, especially if the power keep up good form, tough but i would trade Eddy

[Holz]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

[Mongoose528]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

Martin has looked super good. I would get him.

[ants]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

i would personally get sloane! martin second selwood third

[crowls]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

Why not Murphy as a cheaper option? 

[Holz]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

Why not Murphy as a cheaper option?

reckon all the top teams have him, others are bringing him. I dont think i can catch with him and im not convinced he will be a top 8 mid from here on out.

Sloane Dmart are better players then him

actually considering Docherty as he is looking like the top defender in the comp.

[crowls]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

Why not Murphy as a cheaper option?

reckon all the top teams have him, others are bringing him. I dont think i can catch with him and im not convinced he will be a top 8 mid from here on out.

Sloane Dmart are better players then him

actually considering Docherty as he is looking like the top defender in the comp.

That is the problem I am facing now.   Getting in players who are already in top SC teams doesn't allow you to catch up.  Going POD means risk of falling further behind.   Not going sanidlankwitts has limited my scores this season.   


Martin and Murph look the standout options amongst the Mids.   Martin potential to miss a couple with MRP and Murphy an injury risk.     Would go Martin as he looks like matching Danger/Fyfe as a scoring mid superprem.

[Holz]

ok so if i trade Goldy i can get any mid.

Sloane Selwood Martin are the free im mainly looking at already got Pendles Fyfe Beams Rocky Bont Danger

Why not Murphy as a cheaper option?

reckon all the top teams have him, others are bringing him. I dont think i can catch with him and im not convinced he will be a top 8 mid from here on out.

Sloane Dmart are better players then him

actually considering Docherty as he is looking like the top defender in the comp.

That is the problem I am facing now.   Getting in players who are already in top SC teams doesn't allow you to catch up.  Going POD means risk of falling further behind.   Not going sanidlankwitts has limited my scores this season.   


Martin and Murph look the standout options amongst the Mids.   Martin potential to miss a couple with MRP and Murphy an injury risk.     Would go Martin as he looks like matching Danger/Fyfe as a scoring mid superprem.

Sloane has been the infrom player of the comp in round 2 and 3. Issue with him is big ball winning Brad Crouch coming back

Dusty is on fire and a gun issue for him is if they use him forward more and if not if he stops kicking goals. He wont keep up this scoring if he does he will kick 59 goals this season. He kicked 9 last year.