Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

Gawn vs Goldy +70K

I'm having the same debate. A lot of the feedback I have had said Gawn. Goldy is awfully tempting though, especially coming up against Vardy/Petrie this week

Goldy

[smashbox]

Hanners V Selwood V T. Mitchell V Neale

[TomK]

Hanners V Selwood V T. Mitchell V Neale

Hanners

[Mat0369]

Goldy

Reasoning?

[essendon2]

Houston vs J. Smith (Melb)

[Bully]

Houston vs J. Smith (Melb)

J.Smith

[essendon2]

Houston vs J. Smith (Melb)

J.Smith

Cheers, last one:

Buddy vs T. Lynch (GC)

[Bully]

Houston vs J. Smith (Melb)

J.Smith

Cheers, last one:

Buddy vs T. Lynch (GC)

Buddy (Lynch has round 9 bye)

[Mat0369]

Cheers, last one:

Buddy vs T. Lynch (GC)

I see Tom Lynch as the ideal upgrade target. His bye you still need to fill a full team and then he plays all through the regular bye weeks. I'd go with Buddy based on that alone.

[GoLions]

Goldy

Reasoning?

He has been up the top for a while now, and with most rucks generally struggling to back up elite seasons, think he's a better starting pick than Gawn.

[Mat0369]

He has been up the top for a while now, and with most rucks generally struggling to back up elite seasons, think he's a better starting pick than Gawn.

That's pretty much been my reasoning for going with him originally. Gawn's floor is unknown, I'm still pretty sure Goldy's floor is 105 which is still probably good enough for top 2 at the position.

[hawkboy80]

Swallow & Taranto or Beams & Otten, (had to move Hibberd to mids)

[hawkboy80]

Swallow & Taranto or Beams & Otten, (had to move Hibberd to mids)

Swallow being out already makes me nervous about his durability

[Mat0369]

I don't think you can risk sitting that much cash in round 1. Go with Beams and Otten.

[tkringle]

GHS vs Taranto as Swallow's replacement?