Player X v Player Y

[crowls]

Florent v Simpkin v Bowes v WHE rank them in order

WHE > Florent > Simpkin > Bowes



Otten vs Houston vs WHE? (Yes I know Otten is a defender :P )

Lot of money for fwd rookies.    Why?    Butler has already shown you can get cash generation from cheap rookies.    Even if you missed his points last night you can corrective trade one of the expensive buggers in your list to butler to get his cash rise.     

If butler scores crap next week I don't even think I will make a corrective trade to get him... name me three more rookies 130k or less in the forward line with good JS

Difference is the mid price rookies need to average 10+ points more than the cheaper rookies.  Is they JS better?  Probably not.  I like Florent f5 but not sure his JS is worth it.   I have simpkin at the moment and questioning that decision as well.   If there JS is not better the likelihood is they will not average more than cheaper rookies.   ATM I have houston, eddy, picket fwd, and parfit in mids.   Then there is butler.    As stated if he duds next week people will need to decide on if to start him.   However he will get a good first price rise and be capable of an early trade.     

[Maca24]

Bowes + Hanners vs Witts + Treloar

[crowls]

goldy/strndica vs witts/steele


witts and 200K vs ryder

[Jay]

Bowes + Hanners vs Witts + Treloar

Treloar & Witts. Think Hanners and Treloar are the same, and then would rather Witts for his ruck coverage.


JPK & Florent vs. Sloane & WHE

[Maca24]

Bowes + Hanners vs Witts + Treloar

Treloar & Witts. Think Hanners and Treloar are the same, and then would rather Witts for his ruck coverage.


JPK & Florent vs. Sloane & WHE

Thanks :)

JPK and Florent, Sloane is underdone and I prefer Florent over WHE.

[Torpedo10]

Treloar + Ben Long (Bank Butlers 98 and loop Eddy/Butler until Long comes in) v Titchell + Simpkin

[Maca24]

Treloar + Ben Long (Bank Butlers 98 and loop Eddy/Butler until Long comes in) v Titchell + Simpkin

Option 2, you are assuming Ben Long comes in at all...

[jvalles69]

Alrighty, made a few adjustments and need help with the final piece.  Best defender under 362K.

These are the options I'm looking at: Hurley, Carlisle, Z.Jones, Ramsay or Thurlow?

[Gigantor]

Alrighty, made a few adjustments and need help with the final piece.  Best defender under 362K.

These are the options I'm looking at: Hurley, Carlisle, Z.Jones, Ramsay or Thurlow?

Hurley is 464k

Jones or Thurlow for me

[jvalles69]

Alrighty, made a few adjustments and need help with the final piece.  Best defender under 362K.

These are the options I'm looking at: Hurley, Carlisle, Z.Jones, Ramsay or Thurlow?

Hurley is 464k

Jones or Thurlow for me

Lol, I read Hurley instead of Hartley! Thank flower for that!

Was on Thurlow all pre season, I have this gut feeling that he got injured that last JLT and will miss this week...think I'll roll with Jones and if I need to correct the so be it.

[Ringo]

Treloar v JPK v Hannebery

Rank in order.

JPK, Treloar, Hanners but bot really a lot of difference between them.

[AlexIsOnFire]

McCarthy vs Taranto

Worried about Taranto's security with Coniglio and Lids to come inz

[Samsturmfels]

McCarthy vs Taranto

Worried about Taranto's security with Coniglio and Lids to come inz

Taranto

[smashbox]

Bont Vs Hanners Vs JPK

really wanna go the bont!

[lukebomber]

Trealor & Parker vs Hanners/JPK & Jack Steven?