Player X v Player Y

[Bones Bombers]

Getting a bit antsy as the season opener approaches.

Jelwood vs Titchell +$40k.

Have had Titch in the team for a week or 2 but starting to wonder if its the best option in a new team where he might get tagged. Although as the number 1 mid he should get plenty of opportunity to show his best.
Jelwood is everywhere when you watch a Geelong game and Danger gets most of the attention from the opposition.

[crowls]

Doc, Treloar, Taranto
Vs
Laird, Jaeger, Buddy

1st option based on points

option 2 easy.

Laird i can see matching Doch and Doch is over priced.

JOM is a much better pick then Taranto given he is only 100k more. He should beat him by 20+ points.

While I love Treloar i reckon Buddy can come within 20 easy.

Doc 105 + Treloar 110 + Taranto 75 = 290
Vs
Laird 100 + JOM 90 + Buddy 95 = 285
Close one but that was my logic.

Disagree as probablity of taranto 70+ is 50/50 at best.   JOM floor is probably 90 and upside is 105.   

[tommy10]

Doc, Treloar, Taranto
Vs
Laird, Jaeger, Buddy

1st option based on points

option 2 easy.

Laird i can see matching Doch and Doch is over priced.

JOM is a much better pick then Taranto given he is only 100k more. He should beat him by 20+ points.

While I love Treloar i reckon Buddy can come within 20 easy.

Doc 105 + Treloar 110 + Taranto 75 = 290
Vs
Laird 100 + JOM 90 + Buddy 95 = 285
Close one but that was my logic.

Disagree as probablity of taranto 70+ is 50/50 at best.   JOM floor is probably 90 and upside is 105.   

One can argue that Treloar's and Doc's upside is 115 and 110 respectively

[whynot102]

McMillian, Tuohy, Bob Murphy or Roberton at D3

[TomK]

McMillian, Tuohy, Bob Murphy or Roberton at D3

Too many good premium defensive options to be considering any of these but if I had to, probably Roberton.

[TomK]

Buddy, TMitch, Houston (F6)
vs
Ryder, Treloar, Turner (F6)
vs
Ryder, TMitch, WHE

[My Chumps]

McMillian, Tuohy, Bob Murphy or Roberton at D3

I like Roberton and Macmillian. Would probably just give the edge to JMac

[billnats]

Steele and Greene
Vs
O'Meara and McRae

[Mongoose528]

Buddy, TMitch, Houston (F6)
vs
Ryder, Treloar, Turner (F6)
vs
Ryder, TMitch, WHE

Ryder, TMitch, WHE imo

Steele and Greene
Vs
O'Meara and McRae

JOM and Macrae

[tkringle]

Roughead vs Steele?

[LordSneeze]

Roughead vs Steele?

Roughy for me.

Steele is unproven and is just being hyped through the roof without having any evidence to back up that he will be a premium. At the moment it is people just jumping on the he will play midfield.
While I agree that he is likely to improve his average at his price you really are hoping he turns into a premium, at best I see an 85 average, more likely going to be a 75-80 though.

[Rusty00]

Still struggling to get a final team I'm totally happy with :-\

1 - Lloyd/MacMillan + Swallow + Goldstein + Taranto
2 - Thurlow + Mid <$478k + Goldstein + Taranto
3 - Thurlow + Macrae + Goldstein + Florent
4 - Howe + Selwood + Witts + Taranto

[ants]

thurlow j kelly goldy taranto

marchbank or taranto

[CunningStunt]

Still struggling to get a final team I'm totally happy with :-\

1 - Lloyd/MacMillan + Swallow + Goldstein + Taranto
2 - Thurlow + Mid <$478k + Goldstein + Taranto
3 - Thurlow + Macrae + Goldstein + Florent
4 - Howe + Selwood + Witts + Taranto

Easy decision for mine - option 1

Shaw v Docherty as my D1?

[Rusty00]

marchbank or taranto

Marchbank for me - stronger job security

Shaw v Docherty as my D1?

Shaw for me, longer history of premium scores. Can't go wrong with either really though and Docherty has a better bye when used with Laird and Adams