Player X v Player Y

[crowls]

neither, drop down to marchbank or if you have him down to a cheap rookie.     alternative up to a low 400k  mcmillan, touhy, etc

I already have Marchbank and McMillan.

My backs are Laird, Adams, McMillan, Thurlow, Marchbank, Hampton

Would still drop down to a cheaper rookie.    however if i had to have one would be jones

[Samsturmfels]

neither, drop down to marchbank or if you have him down to a cheap rookie.     alternative up to a low 400k  mcmillan, touhy, etc

I already have Marchbank and McMillan.

My backs are Laird, Adams, McMillan, Thurlow, Marchbank, Hampton

Would still drop down to a cheaper rookie.    however if i had to have one would be jones

trade one of thurlow or marchbank to a rookie

[frenzy]

Greene v Caddy?

Caddy



Lloyd & Hurn (D2/D3) & Higgins (F3) + $34.4K vs. Adams/Laird (D2), Thurlow (D3), Buddy (F3) +$59K vs. Llloyd (D2), Thurlow (D3) Rocky

last option for me there

[My Chumps]

My conundrum: Tom Lynch + Taranto vs Wingard + Nankervis

Lloyd & Hurn (D2/D3) & Higgins (F3) + $34.4K vs. Adams/Laird (D2), Thurlow (D3), Buddy (F3) +$59K vs. Llloyd (D2), Thurlow (D3) Rocky

Second option but would rather...

Zac Jones vs Thurlow for D4?

Jones

Caddy, Higgins, Nank, Houston vs Franklin Green Taranto and Butler

Second option

Tmitch + Sandilands vs Gawn + Swallow

Tmitch + Sandi but I'd still try to squeeze Swallow in

Greene v Caddy?

For the love of god Greene

[Torpedo10]

My conundrum: Tom Lynch + Taranto vs Wingard + Nankervis

Lloyd & Hurn (D2/D3) & Higgins (F3) + $34.4K vs. Adams/Laird (D2), Thurlow (D3), Buddy (F3) +$59K vs. Llloyd (D2), Thurlow (D3) Rocky

Second option but would rather...

Zac Jones vs Thurlow for D4?

Jones

Caddy, Higgins, Nank, Houston vs Franklin Green Taranto and Butler

Second option

Tmitch + Sandilands vs Gawn + Swallow

Tmitch + Sandi but I'd still try to squeeze Swallow in

Greene v Caddy?

For the love of god Greene

Lynch and Taranto will deliver more points IMO.

Florent or Kayne Turner?

[vtaced]

Lynch vs Greene?

[Gandalf123]

My conundrum: Tom Lynch + Taranto vs Wingard + Nankervis

Lloyd & Hurn (D2/D3) & Higgins (F3) + $34.4K vs. Adams/Laird (D2), Thurlow (D3), Buddy (F3) +$59K vs. Llloyd (D2), Thurlow (D3) Rocky

Second option but would rather...

Zac Jones vs Thurlow for D4?

Jones

Caddy, Higgins, Nank, Houston vs Franklin Green Taranto and Butler

Second option

Tmitch + Sandilands vs Gawn + Swallow

Tmitch + Sandi but I'd still try to squeeze Swallow in

Greene v Caddy?

For the love of god Greene

Lynch and Taranto will deliver more points IMO.

Florent or Kayne Turner?

Florent!
And lynch to the above, even though he has rd 9 bye!

Swallow and Taranto v Nank and Barret(or similar rookie) keeping in mind that Nank provides cover for sandi.

[Mantis]

From what I've read turner has the better job security. Turner could be a rollercoaster with scoring though. I'm considering Bowes over both atm but that's not settled

Team is nearly set but struggling with this one

Treloar vs Jelwood

Treloar gives me another VC option as I have Danger JPK Hanners Fyfe.

Jelwood the better bye and not a bad starting fixture.

[crowls]

From what I've read turner has the better job security. Turner could be a rollercoaster with scoring though. I'm considering Bowes over both atm but that's not settled

Team is nearly set but struggling with this one

Treloar vs Jelwood

Treloar gives me another VC option as I have Danger JPK Hanners Fyfe.

Jelwood the better bye and not a bad starting fixture.

you know the answer already.

[js19]

Doc, Treloar, Taranto
Vs
Laird, Jaeger, Buddy

[Holz]

Caddy, Higgins, Nank, Houston vs Franklin Green Taranto and Butler

Caddy, Higgins, Nank, Houston

Franklin Nank Taranto Bowes/Turner + cash

[tommy10]

Doc, Treloar, Taranto
Vs
Laird, Jaeger, Buddy

1st option based on points

[Mahogany]

Roughead or Higgins ( have the cash to upgrade to Higgins but currently have roughy )

[Holz]

Doc, Treloar, Taranto
Vs
Laird, Jaeger, Buddy

1st option based on points

option 2 easy.

Laird i can see matching Doch and Doch is over priced.

JOM is a much better pick then Taranto given he is only 100k more. He should beat him by 20+ points.

While I love Treloar i reckon Buddy can come within 20 easy.

[petefisker]

Another juicy one -

T.Mitchell v J.Kelly
Had zero coin left to get in 2 playing rookies, I needed $78K.
After an hour i dropped T.Mitchell $565K and brought in J.Kelly $473K
Saving me $92K and being able the solid rookies in.
I also believe both Mitchell and Kelly are keepers and possibly make that Top10 mids.