Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

i need to pick three of:
Taranto* vs WHE vs McCarthy* vs Turner vs Bowes*   *= currently running with

Taranto, Bowes, Turner imo

[GoLions]

D2...?
Shaw. (Adams vs Laird). Howe. + Rookies....

Laird over Adams for me, think he will push 100 and Adams could definitely beat that, but a much greater injury risk

[GoLions]

JPK vs Jelwood?!

JPK slightly over Jelwood but your splitting hairs

Agree and I have both.

I'd possibly have Jelwood over JPK tbh, but had both in my team over the last few weeks, along with Treloar and Zorko. Still haven't made up my mind ahaha

[GoLions]

Grundy v Stef Martin

Stef, has gone 110+ in both 2014 and 2015. But if Archie is named round 1 (although I don't see him playing more than 3 games for the year if Stef is 100% fit), then go with Grundy.

[GoLions]

JOM (95) M7 vs. Roughy (90) F4

I prefer JOM, see Roughy going closer to 85 tbqh

[Keeper27]

JOM (95) M7 vs. Roughy (90) F4

I prefer JOM, see Roughy going closer to 85 tbqh

85? hmm... not that bad.

WHE & Taranto vs. Roughy & Rookie under $148k (Houston/black/Parfitt)

[Bully]

JOM (95) M7 vs. Roughy (90) F4

I prefer JOM, see Roughy going closer to 85 tbqh

85? hmm... not that bad.

WHE & Taranto vs. Roughy & Rookie under $148k (Houston/black/Parfitt)

Roughy & Parfitt

[AaronKirk]

JPK vs Jelwood?!

JPK slightly over Jelwood but your splitting hairs

Agree and I have both.

I'd possibly have Jelwood over JPK tbh, but had both in my team over the last few weeks, along with Treloar and Zorko. Still haven't made up my mind ahaha

Geelong do not play at Simonds stadium until round 9. Selwood averaged 124.38 there in 8 games last year.

I'd would not be starting him as I think he could drop a little before bringing him in. At games at all other venues including the Qualifying Final he averaged 103.46 in 2016

[benny_fraz]

Witts (R2) vs WHE (F3)

which one will average higher?

[Bully]

Witts (R2) vs WHE (F3)

which one will average higher?

Witts easily.

[crowls]

Is Macrae actually a must ??

I havent had him pre season. I just dont know why i donr rate him. I currently have Franklin and Lynch instead

Pick 2 of Franklin, Lynch and Macrae

If in doubt pick the mid, this is a standard deviation issue. Chances are both Franklin & Lynch will drop by more than Macrae.

heed the voice of wisdom

[uncleswagy]

Witts (R2) vs WHE (F3)

which one will average higher?

Witts easily.

Id rather have WHE in my team but not at F3

[mattttwillll]

Newman (D7) + Gawn (R1) + Roughead (F3) + Nankervis (F4)

                                         VS

Laird (D3) + Nankervis (R1) + Macrae (F2) + Rookie <130k (F7)

[uncleswagy]

Newman (D7) + Gawn (R1) + Roughead (F3) + Nankervis (F4)

                                         VS

Laird (D3) + Nankervis (R1) + Macrae (F2) + Rookie <130k (F7)

Top one, saw nank R1 and didnt have to look further

[batt]

Newman (D7) + Gawn (R1) + Roughead (F3) + Nankervis (F4)

                                         VS

Laird (D3) + Nankervis (R1) + Macrae (F2) + Rookie <130k (F7)

I'd take the first option.

Ryder/Roughy/McCarthy vs Lynch/Nankervis/Black.