Player X v Player Y

[SilverLion]

Marchbank vs. Thurlow

[Millsy999]

The Bont vs Titchell?

Tmac & Swallow vs Roo & Marchbank?

[Bluesman]

Marchbank vs. Thurlow

Marchbank just (considering price mainly)

[Bluesman]

The Bont vs Titchell?

Tmac & Swallow vs Roo & Marchbank?

Titchell just

Roo & Marchbank as 1 definite keeper and cheaper cheapie

[SilverLion]

Another quick one, WHE vs Taranto

[Ringo]

Why not both SL. unless you need extra cash.

[thornz23]

Witts Ryder and Touhy  vs  Gawn Steele and Otten?

[Cookie Monster]

Witts Ryder and Touhy  vs  Gawn Steele and Otten?

Why not make Gawn into Hickey or even Nank and to a lesser extent Witts? If he is the only ruck selected Rd1 then sure have him.

I'd say Witts-Steele and use the cash to get someone better. Or pick Touhy and upgrade elsewhere if needed.



I'm sure this has been said before but...


JPK v Parker v Hannebury

I'm sure you can't really go wrong with either.

[thornz23]

I'd have the 3 swans in that order

[Money Shot]

Hanners, JPK, Parker but all will be top 15 mids.

Tom Mitchell and Tom Boyd v David Swallow and Max Gawn
(For Fantasy btw)

[Bubbles]

McCarthy v Taranto

McCarthy =  30's and 40's with great JS and the odd half decent game
Or
Taranto = 65-75 with shakey JS but a much higher scoring ceiling! feel like it would only take 2 or 3 bad games in a row for him to be dropped back to the 2's.

[tommy10]

Lloyd vs Tuohy?

[eg6914]

McCarthy v Taranto

McCarthy =  30's and 40's with great JS and the odd half decent game
Or
Taranto = 65-75 with shakey JS but a much higher scoring ceiling! feel like it would only take 2 or 3 bad games in a row for him to be dropped back to the 2's.

Can't go wrong with either (ideally you should have both), but id start taranto based on scoring potential

Lloyd vs Tuohy?

Fell like neither will be top 10 defenders but if I had to pick one id go lloyd

i need to pick three of:
Taranto* vs WHE vs McCarthy* vs Turner vs Bowes*   *= currently running with

[Woppa15]

D2...?
Shaw. (Adams vs Laird). Howe. + Rookies....

[Sabretooth Tigers]

D2...?
Shaw. (Adams vs Laird). Howe. + Rookies....

Yeah for D2, got Doc D1 and Laird D3. Also up front need one of the rookies to play got Taranto D5

:)  Taranto  M  or  F  5 ?