Player X v Player Y

[aussied]

Smokies from Last year i was hoping to get up and going, and as usual i wont pick them and they pop 105+ just like sidebottom last year.

M. Duncan vs D. Shiel

Thoughts? 

Duncan had foot injury which interrupted his preseason last year caddy now out of the picture dangerwood will be offloading alot of the pill to an outside player i see being either guthrie or duncan , JLT 2017 with a TOG PPM *100 AVG of 150.19 in which he was playing half games and scoring avg 80

Dylan shiel has the support, in which allows him to be let loose so wont get tagged, winning team, like the way he goes about his footy.

thinking both players can up +10 and be 100 avg players this year.

[Bully]

Smokies from Last year i was hoping to get up and going, and as usual i wont pick them and they pop 105+ just like sidebottom last year.

M. Duncan vs D. Shiel

Thoughts? 

Duncan had foot injury which interrupted his preseason last year caddy now out of the picture dangerwood will be offloading alot of the pill to an outside player i see being either guthrie or duncan , JLT 2017 with a TOG PPM *100 AVG of 150.19 in which he was playing half games and scoring avg 80

Dylan shiel has the support, in which allows him to be let loose so wont get tagged, winning team, like the way he goes about his footy.

thinking both players can up +10 and be 100 avg players this year.

I don't like either but if I had to choose I would take Shiel.

[tommy10]

Swallow and WHE vs Steele and Rookie

Also Rocky vs Selwood vs JPK in which order?

[Bully]

Swallow and WHE vs Steele and Rookie

Also Rocky vs Selwood vs JPK in which order?

Swallow & WHE

JPK, Selwood, Rocky

[Bubbles]

San Docherty v Heath Shaw

Would of been done before but interested to see what people think, Shaw's ownership has gone through the roof but for good reason he is a superstar and doesn't look like slowing down

[thornz23]

Witts Ryder and Touhy  vs  Gawn Steele and Otten?

[quinny88]

San Docherty v Heath Shaw

Would of been done before but interested to see what people think, Shaw's ownership has gone through the roof but for good reason he is a superstar and doesn't look like slowing down

I have Shaw slightly ahead purely based on the fact that he has the runs on the board. Think we will all have both by seasons end though

[Money Shot]

Trealor v Rocky

Franklin v Greene v Caddy

[Blues Blues Blues]

Trealor v Rocky

Franklin v Greene v Caddy

Treloar

Tough one - prob in order you have them

[Bluesman]

Docherty & WHE versus
Z.Jones & Franklin?

[Mongoose528]

Docherty & WHE versus
Z.Jones & Franklin?

Docherty and WHE imo

JPK V Treloar?

[Mantis]

JPK - proven sc beast

Hannerbury + mid rookie (m8) + defence rookie (d4)
Vs
O'meara + Swallow (m8) + Marchbank

Current Mids
Danger JPK Treloar Jelwood Fyfe Beams

[Mantis]

Am now thinking of going from

Adams (D3) & Swallow
to
Rookie & Hannerbury

Removes some of the risk in the team and Leaves enough cash also to go Goldy to Gawn if spencer is not named

[Bubbles]

Turner v Bowes

[Gigantor]

Turner v Bowes

Turner, better JS