Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

JPK & Bowes vs TMitch & Taranto (assuming both rookies play)

JPK and Bowes

[uncleswagy]

Treloar + fwd rook v brodie + caddy

Edit: if picking treloar, heeney will be f2

[BomberSam]

Hannebery v Treloar

I reckon Treloar can improve his average, i would expect Hanners to stay the same or drop a bit

Sound logic here.

Treloar is younger and the Pies midfield will be the key in Pies success , there may be some uncertainty in the swans midfield with Mitchell leaving meaning other players will get rotated ,so scoring may be muddled for a couple of weeks. And if you were to pick a swans midfielder i would go with Mr consistency JPK

Interestingly in 2016, Mr. Consistency's standard deviation was 21.9 whereas Hannebery's was 21.5, the more consistent player. I am not doubting JPK's status as a Mr. Consistency, but I wouldn't use consistency as a means for justifying a JPK selection over a Hannebery selection. I think they are both absolute guns that will fall in the 112-117 range, and I am starting both.

Ahh fair point
Fair play picking both, i just prefer JPK :)

Contested beast.

[dmac07]

Treloar + fwd rook v brodie + caddy

Edit: if picking treloar, heeney will be f2

Brodie and Caddy simply because there arent any good fwd rookies at this poijt and i imagine heeney at f2 leaves that line very weak

[tommy10]

Shaw and Prestia vs Vince and Bont

Tough one. I'd rather Howe and Sloane, I reckon you might afford that.

Like Howe too Wato, but have Shaw and Adams at D1 & D2, so don't want another pie. Unless I swap Howe for Adams?? So leads me to my question Howe vs Adams?

[dmac07]

Shaw, Beams, Caddy vs Laird, Bont, Nank.

D2/M6/F4

[Ringo]

Slightly leaning to Shaw, Beams, Caddy but not a lot of difference between the 2.

[lmollica]

Roughead v Caddy

[Sven]

Roughead v Caddy

Conservatively, I'd say Caddy. Roughy will likely average 90, think Caddy will be around 95 mark.

[Sven]

Big one here...

Def Rookie (not Ryan, Stewart or EV-W) + Hanners + Treloar + Nank + Bowes

OR

Marchbank + Pendles + Mid Rookie + Gawn + WH-E.

[Spite]

Big one here...

Def Rookie (not Ryan, Stewart or EV-W) + Hanners + Treloar + Nank + Bowes

OR

Marchbank + Pendles + Mid Rookie + Gawn + WH-E.

Top option for me

[tommy10]

Big one here...

Def Rookie (not Ryan, Stewart or EV-W) + Hanners + Treloar + Nank + Bowes

OR

Marchbank + Pendles + Mid Rookie + Gawn + WH-E.

Top option for me

+1 easily

[Sven]

Big one here...

Def Rookie (not Ryan, Stewart or EV-W) + Hanners + Treloar + Nank + Bowes

OR

Marchbank + Pendles + Mid Rookie + Gawn + WH-E.

Top option for me

+1 easily

Yeah, thought that was going to be the case. Just toying with ideas to go from Nankilands to Gawndilands.

Cheers.

[uncleswagy]

Big one here...

Def Rookie (not Ryan, Stewart or EV-W) + Hanners + Treloar + Nank + Bowes

OR

Marchbank + Pendles + Mid Rookie + Gawn + WH-E.

Top option for me

+1 easily

Yeah, thought that was going to be the case. Just toying with ideas to go from Nankilands to Gawndilands.

Cheers.

In its self i agree the top one is easily better but the nankilands combo is a huge risk

[john23132]

Bont v Selwood  :-[