Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

crowls

Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on March 03, 2017, 12:52:41 PM
Quote from: Sven on March 03, 2017, 12:12:02 PM
Higgins v Petracca v Ryder v Roughy

All midpricers all with huge upside this year. Can only fit one though...

Petracca,  Higgins ( only for 4 - 6 rds, then upgrade ),  Roughead,  Ryder.   IMO  Nankervis much more value and potential than Ryder.
Go to disagree Sabretootch.    Petracca is only a second year player.  will lack the consistency required.  Agree Higgins could pay off if you get him at the start of a streak of form.   roughy to me is still a bit of a punt but worth it at his starting price.   

gone off Ryder as my backup for Sandi.   Instead gone to Darcy as f8 and ruck cover.   May still upgrade him for Nank before Round 1 or see if Pruess is going to get games.   

Sabretooth Tigers

 :)

Z Merritt  v  L Neale,  v  D Zorko  v  D Martin  v  R Sloane  for  M.5  with Fyfe,  O'Meara  and  W Brodie  then  Barrett,  Wigg  and  Picket to follow.

:-\

Sabretooth Tigers

Quote from: crowls on March 03, 2017, 12:57:25 PM
Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on March 03, 2017, 12:52:41 PM
Quote from: Sven on March 03, 2017, 12:12:02 PM
Higgins v Petracca v Ryder v Roughy

All midpricers all with huge upside this year. Can only fit one though...

Petracca,  Higgins ( only for 4 - 6 rds, then upgrade ),  Roughead,  Ryder.   IMO  Nankervis much more value and potential than Ryder.
Go to disagree Sabretootch.    Petracca is only a second year player.  will lack the consistency required.  Agree Higgins could pay off if you get him at the start of a streak of form.   roughy to me is still a bit of a punt but worth it at his starting price.   

gone off Ryder as my backup for Sandi.   Instead gone to Darcy as f8 and ruck cover.   May still upgrade him for Nank before Round 1 or see if Pruess is going to get games.

You may be right crowls, I haven't got him in my team but think he may be something very special, even as a second year player.  But not confident enough to pick him. 

crowls

Why not Titch  ST...    Also would prioritise whichever player balances your byes better.   

Sabretooth Tigers

Quote from: crowls on March 03, 2017, 01:04:00 PM
Why not Titch  ST...    Also would prioritise whichever player balances your byes better.

Nice suggestion crowls. It would come down to either Titch or Zerritt bye wise. Like Titch's price, thanks mate, cheers and all the best.

:)

GoLions

Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on March 03, 2017, 01:00:28 PM
:)

Z Merritt  v  L Neale,  v  D Zorko  v  D Martin  v  R Sloane  for  M.5  with Fyfe,  O'Meara  and  W Brodie  then  Barrett,  Wigg  and  Picket to follow.

:-\
I like Sloaney if he's good to go round 1

uncleswagy

Quote from: GoLions on March 03, 2017, 02:11:01 PM
Quote from: Sabretooth Tigers on March 03, 2017, 01:00:28 PM
:)

Z Merritt  v  L Neale,  v  D Zorko  v  D Martin  v  R Sloane  for  M.5  with Fyfe,  O'Meara  and  W Brodie  then  Barrett,  Wigg  and  Picket to follow.

:-\
I like Sloaney if he's good to go round 1

+1 for sloaney, i do like Neale better but he has had a super interrupted preseaon

uncleswagy

Pendles + strnadica (loophole) v Treloar + English (if named round 1)

Ringo

Pendles and Strnadica


With Sandi at R2 which combo to give back up. (Still undecided whether to have back up)

Gawn+Nankervis or Goldy+ Ryder (About 10k short of Gawn and Ryder)

Spite

Quote from: uncleswagy on March 03, 2017, 07:03:26 PM
Pendles + strnadica (loophole) v Treloar + English (if named round 1)

First option. Loopholes are seriously underrated in the value they provide!

mattttwillll

Beams + Goldstein      vs        Any Midfielder(600k) + Sandilands + $112,600

The 600k is based on what the added cash would equal to.

billnats

O'Meara & Hrovat
or
J. Kelly & Rookie

Don't like mid-pricers but the forward line is struggling with rookie forward nailed on

billnats

Quote from: Ringo on March 03, 2017, 07:12:54 PM

With Sandi at R2 which combo to give back up. (Still undecided whether to have back up)

Gawn+Nankervis or Goldy+ Ryder (About 10k short of Gawn and Ryder)

Gawn & Nankervis

jvalles69

Quote from: billnats on March 03, 2017, 09:17:33 PM
O'Meara & Hrovat
or
J. Kelly & Rookie

Don't like mid-pricers but the forward line is struggling with rookie forward nailed on

Not sure if I can promote either of these options, but if you must O'Meara and Hrovat.  If another forward rook appears though I'd go O'Meara + rookie.

jvalles69

Quote from: billnats on March 03, 2017, 09:21:46 PM
Quote from: Ringo on March 03, 2017, 07:12:54 PM

With Sandi at R2 which combo to give back up. (Still undecided whether to have back up)

Gawn+Nankervis or Goldy+ Ryder (About 10k short of Gawn and Ryder)

Gawn & Nankervis

Gawn and Nank.