Player X v Player Y

[MC]

Bont vs Titchell vs JPK vs Jelwood

I have 3 of the 4  8)

JPK > Jelwood > Bont > Titch

[Sicko]

MaCrae vs Greene ??

[Mongoose528]

MaCrae vs Greene ??

Macrae easily.

[tommy10]

heeney vs gunston

Heeney

GUNston

+1

[tommy10]

Shaw and Heeney vs Adams and Caddy

[uncleswagy]

Shaw and Heeney vs Adams and Caddy

this is probably the toughest one ive seen tbh
id go adams and caddy, but maybe im just saying that because thats what i have

Shaws certainly the safer defender but the heeney vs caddy debate id imagine would be 50/50 between the community but id favour caddy

[MC]

Shaw and Heeney vs Adams and Caddy

Tough! Only way to do it (for mine) is to weigh up what I predict them to score:
Shaw 100-105 + Heeney 90?  VS  Adams 100 + Caddy 95

190-195 apiece for mine, though the durability of Shaw and Heeney I think tips that pair over the edge!

[Spite]

Rockliff + 123k fwd rookie (currently McKay - on field) vs Higgins/Henney + JOM.

Have no midpricers otherwise.

Thanks!

[TomK]

Rockliff + 123k fwd rookie (currently McKay - on field) vs Higgins/Henney + JOM.

Have no midpricers otherwise.

Thanks!

Always something including Rocky :P

[Spite]

Rockliff + 123k fwd rookie (currently McKay - on field) vs Higgins/Henney + JOM.

Have no midpricers otherwise.

Thanks!

Always something including Rocky :P

Haha then what about this?

JPK, Grundy, McKay, D.Cameron to JOM, Sandi, Caddy, McCluggage.

I would have gone the first option if I knew those forward rookies were playing but unfortunately it looks unlikely! :(

[TomK]

Rockliff + 123k fwd rookie (currently McKay - on field) vs Higgins/Henney + JOM.

Have no midpricers otherwise.

Thanks!

Always something including Rocky :P

Haha then what about this?

JPK, Grundy, McKay, D.Cameron to JOM, Sandi, Caddy, McCluggage.

I would have gone the first option if I knew those forward rookies were playing but unfortunately it looks unlikely! :(

The first option is much safer if the rookies were to play but the second has much more scoring potential. I'd probably go option two.

[Spite]

Rockliff + 123k fwd rookie (currently McKay - on field) vs Higgins/Henney + JOM.

Have no midpricers otherwise.

Thanks!

Always something including Rocky :P

Haha then what about this?

JPK, Grundy, McKay, D.Cameron to JOM, Sandi, Caddy, McCluggage.

I would have gone the first option if I knew those forward rookies were playing but unfortunately it looks unlikely! :(

The first option is much safer if the rookies were to play but the second has much more scoring potential. I'd probably go option two.

Thanks man, second option it is!

[Sven]

Higgins v Petracca v Ryder v Roughy

All midpricers all with huge upside this year. Can only fit one though...

[GoLions]

Higgins v Petracca v Ryder v Roughy

All midpricers all with huge upside this year. Can only fit one though...

Higgins > Roughy > Ryder > Petracca

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Higgins v Petracca v Ryder v Roughy

All midpricers all with huge upside this year. Can only fit one though...

Petracca,  Higgins ( only for 4 - 6 rds, then upgrade ),  Roughead,  Ryder.   IMO  Nankervis much more value and potential than Ryder.