Player X v Player Y

[crowls]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

Ryder 92-95,  Macrae 90+, Caddy 95+, Heeny  85-100, Roughy 90-100

[LordSneeze]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

Ryder 92-95,  Macrae 90+, Caddy 95+, Heeny  85-100, Roughy 90-100

Ryder - 90 (starting to get tempted on him given a few things I have seen at the port trainings.)
Macrae - 95
Caddy - 90 (Could be anything really)
Heeney - 85
Roughy - 90

[Holz]

Grundy + Beams +  Roughy

Gawn + Beams  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

Grundy Ablett/JPK  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

[MC]

Grundy + Beams +  Roughy

Gawn + Beams  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

Grundy Ablett/JPK  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

So I gather you've got roughly 1.25-1.3m for those 3 spots?
I'd be inclined to get a cheaper rookie over those 3 suggested forwards to free up 60k or so, Black from Geelong is looking the goods as an option.

If I had to pick from your 3 options, I'd go for option 2, Beams when fit is easily a top-10 mid. His fitness is a risk though, and the 60k difference between Kennedy and Turner could become around 120k if you went Black, allowing Beams up to a 550k mid, not far off Bont/Titch etc.

[Holz]

Grundy + Beams +  Roughy

Gawn + Beams  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

Grundy Ablett/JPK  + Turner/MccCarth/M.Kennnedy

So I gather you've got roughly 1.25-1.3m for those 3 spots?
I'd be inclined to get a cheaper rookie over those 3 suggested forwards to free up 60k or so, Black from Geelong is looking the goods as an option.

If I had to pick from your 3 options, I'd go for option 2, Beams when fit is easily a top-10 mid. His fitness is a risk though, and the 60k difference between Kennedy and Turner could become around 120k if you went Black, allowing Beams up to a 550k mid, not far off Bont/Titch etc.

I got Black Schoey and Eddy

[Mongoose528]

Tom Mitchell/Bont + Roughead v Beams + Macrae

[tommy10]

Tom Mitchell/Bont + Roughead v Beams + Macrae

Bont and Roughy

Treloar vs JPK. Already have Danger and Pendles.

[BomberSam]

Tom Mitchell/Bont + Roughead v Beams + Macrae

Bont and Roughy

Treloar vs JPK. Already have Danger and Pendles.

JPK for me.

[MC]

Tom Mitchell/Bont + Roughead v Beams + Macrae

Bont and Roughy

Treloar vs JPK. Already have Danger and Pendles.

JPK for consistent excellence, Treloar for upside.

[_wato]

Struggling for my M3. Really want JPK Hanners but I'm like $2k off and if things don't lookup on the rookie front it's probs gonna stay that way.

So Neale v Treloar v Jelly.

Leaning towards Jelly but I love Treloar, just don't love all 3 pies on ballers. Think Neale can only improve but he averaged like 33 touches for a 112 average. Fyfe will take so much attention off him which is a HUGE upside

[shaker]

Struggling for my M3. Really want JPK Hanners but I'm like $2k off and if things don't lookup on the rookie front it's probs gonna stay that way.

So Neale v Treloar v Jelly.

Leaning towards Jelly but I love Treloar, just don't love all 3 pies on ballers. Think Neale can only improve but he averaged like 33 touches for a 112 average. Fyfe will take so much attention off him which is a HUGE upside

Selwood is very helpful in the byes trying to get him in my team  I have gone Neale over Fyfe and would love Treloar but can't have everyone so that is probably the hardest choice I have seen .... Selwood for his R12 bye

[crowls]

Selwood is one of the few options in M3-4 area with R12 bye.    Only in last couple of days as I assess my team options for byes is he coming in to consideration.   Orginal plan was upgrade mid year.    Now may have to take selwood instead of Treloar.   


Same thing in forwards,  finding Caddy is now a maybe because of bye coverage.   T Lynch is out due to already have 4 out rd9 and that is all I am willing to sacrifice.   


JPK (11) v Treloar (13) v Hannebury (11) v Selwood (12) v Bont (11) v Titch (13) v Priddis (12) v D Martin (12)


Pick 3 to start and already have 11 players in Rd13 bye before selecting these 3.   

[shaker]

Selwood is one of the few options in M3-4 area with R12 bye.    Only in last couple of days as I assess my team options for byes is he coming in to consideration.   Orginal plan was upgrade mid year.    Now may have to take selwood instead of Treloar.   


Same thing in forwards,  finding Caddy is now a maybe because of bye coverage.   T Lynch is out due to already have 4 out rd9 and that is all I am willing to sacrifice.   


JPK (11) v Treloar (13) v Hannebury (11) v Selwood (12) v Bont (11) v Titch (13) v Priddis (12) v D Martin (12)


Pick 3 to start and already have 11 players in Rd13 bye before selecting these 3.   

Selwood Hanners and Bont if you are ok R11 bye if not and you need another R12 bye I would take Dusty for his POD value

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :-\

Which to start with :-   T Adams  or  R Laird.            Will start 1 and upgrade the other.                                     ;)

[Samsturmfels]

:-\

Which to start with :-   T Adams  or  R Laird.            Will start 1 and upgrade the other.                                     ;)

Start with Adams