Player X v Player Y

[whynot102]

Jobe m6

Roughy (F4) vs. Jobe (M6)

[uncleswagy]

Roughy (F4) vs. Jobe (M6)

roughy

[tommy10]

Jobe m6

Roughy (F4) vs. Jobe (M6)

Yep Jobe M6

[Keeper27]

Jobe m6

Roughy (F4) vs. Jobe (M6)

Yep Jobe M6

Cheers guys
Got 5 premium midst + jobe and swallow

[mattttwillll]

Hartlett + Swallow v   Docherty + Rookie

[GoLions]

Roughy (F4) vs. Jobe (M6)

roughy

[GoLions]

Hartlett + Swallow v   Docherty + Rookie

Hammer and Spitter, but see what Hammer's role is looking like throughout the JLT

[jvalles69]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

[Spite]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

Price order for me. Sorry that's not too helpful!

[Fid]

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

[Keeper27]

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

[Mongoose528]

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

Do y'all think Caddy is better than Macrae?

[Fid]

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

Caddy, Macrae, Ryder, Heeney, Rougy,

Do y'all think Caddy is better than Macrae?

They are very close imo. Caddy will improve with more opportunity @ richmond compared to last season alongside dangerfield.  Macrae spent 40% of game time in the fwd line for only 2 goals last season.  My money will be on Caddy to have a better season at his new club with more opportunity. (last year Caddy averaged more than a goal a game and was rated No 1 for a mid/fwd for score involvements)

[MC]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

Macrae > Caddy > Ryder > Heeney > Rough

[uncleswagy]

Rank 'em.

Caddy, Heeney, Macrae, Rougy, Ryder.

McCrea >/= Caddy . heeney . rough . ryder