Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

dmac07

M6/R2

Bont & Witts vs Swallow & Grundy

lmollica

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on January 06, 2017, 11:39:01 AM
Quote from: Holz on January 06, 2017, 11:01:29 AM
one im struggling with is Taylor Adams v Tom Mcondald.

Tmac had a big last 2/3 of the season and gives some much needed cash.

You know how hard it was for me to give up TMac in Worlds - I rate him so highly and he is locked in my side for 2017. Will be a POD, and I think he can go 95+ comfortably

Adams will be super popular, but I can't see myself starting him. I'm sure he will also go 90+ but he tends to miss games and Collingwood have so much midfield depth so I'm a little uncertain on how he will go - prefe to wait and see so possible upgrade target for me

Personally I'm going for Tom McDonald as well, for the exact same reasons. However if Adams stays fit for the whole season he could definitely rack up some big scores.

lmollica

DEF: Jake Lloyd, has massive potential to score if he improves his disposal, especially tempting at 460k

MID: Matty Crouch, expected to explode this year and will also have more time on the ball with the Crows planning to reduce Scotty Thompsons midfield minutes and the departure of lyons, priced nicely at 505k however he is yet to play a full season.

RUCK: Stef Martin, has had averages of 111 and 110 in past seasons, however burnt me for the most of last season with an average of 89. This years ruck stocks are fragile and priced at 488k also a factor. Still on my never again list after starting him last year.

FWD: Touk Miller, priced at 428k, has huge scoring potential, FWD/MID DPP, scored 6 tons last season including 3 in the last 3 rounds. The only catch is the return and addition of many suns midfielders, including GAJ, Swallow, Lyons and Hanley, may prevent him from getting enough midfield minutes to haul some big scores

Fid

S Martin, Heeney, J Roughead, Gallacci  V  Sandilands, Caddy, Ryder, McCluggage

Mongoose528


uncleswagy

Quote from: Fid on February 14, 2017, 07:30:07 PM
S Martin, Heeney, J Roughead, Gallacci  V  Sandilands, Caddy, Ryder, McCluggage
first group, cant trust sandi

Padawan


uncleswagy

Quote from: Padawan on February 15, 2017, 12:19:33 PM
Treloar, Sloane, Bont

Sloane, has a very favourable first 10-12 rounds

crowls

S martin, Swallow vs Sandi  SMurf

tommy10


tommy10

Pendles and Vince/JJ vs Treloar and Rance

Mongoose528

Quote from: tommy10 on February 16, 2017, 12:38:47 AM
Pendles and Vince/JJ vs Treloar and Rance

Can't go wrong either way, but I would go for Treloar + Rance

Peter

Treloar and Rance in my squad

Woppa15

Shaw, Rance, Howe. Vs Docherty, Laird, McDonald

_wato