Player X v Player Y

[Sven]

D2/M5/R2

H.Shaw, D.Swallow, B.Grundy

Vs

T.Adams, Heppell, Sandilands

I'd personally go Shaw/Swallow/Grundy. There's less risk there. Adams missed a few last year, Sandi injury prone and Heppell is an unknown.

Similarly, anyone help with... M5/M6/F4

M. Murphy/D.Beams, D. Swallow, J. Macrae

or

T. Rockliff/A. Treloar, D. Swallow, J. Roughead

or

M. Murphy, J. Watson/D. Beams, J. Roughead

Cheers!!  :D

[_wato]

Similarly, anyone help with... M5/M6/F4

M. Murphy/D.Beams, D. Swallow, J. Macrae

or

T. Rockliff/A. Treloar, D. Swallow, J. Roughead

or

M. Murphy, J. Watson/D. Beams, J. Roughead

Cheers!!  :D

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

[Kenny27]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.


Hanners, Treloar, Ablett, Jelly

[GCSkiwi]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

[Gandalf123]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

Ryder

[LordSneeze]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

Ryder

Why not put Witts on Ruck bench and bring in another FWD rookie of which there are looking to be plenty?
2 cash cows + cover for Sandi, without the need to be running a non prem on the field as cover.

[Bully]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

Ryder

Why not put Witts on Ruck bench and bring in another FWD rookie of which there are looking to be plenty?
2 cash cows + cover for Sandi, without the need to be running a non prem on the field as cover.

Ryder will be sole ruckman, that usually entails 85+.

[fasttrack13]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

Ryder

Why not put Witts on Ruck bench and bring in another FWD rookie of which there are looking to be plenty?
2 cash cows + cover for Sandi, without the need to be running a non prem on the field as cover.

Ryder will be sole ruckman, that usually entails 85+.

You can't decide until RD 1 Really
Ryder is safe, will go 85+
For me nankervis has a very high ceiling if given a full run at the ruck, he's pretty much shane mumford with extremely sticky jukes. If he's named sole ruck round 1 i'd be tempted to lock him in. Unfortunately Vickery void is what he is likely to fill

[Bully]

Rank in order for M3.

Ablett, Treloar, Jelly, Hanners.

Hanners, Gablett, Jelly, Treloar


Ryder vs Nank as R/F Sandi cover

Ryder

Why not put Witts on Ruck bench and bring in another FWD rookie of which there are looking to be plenty?
2 cash cows + cover for Sandi, without the need to be running a non prem on the field as cover.

Ryder will be sole ruckman, that usually entails 85+.

You can't decide until RD 1 Really
Ryder is safe, will go 85+
For me nankervis has a very high ceiling if given a full run at the ruck, he's pretty much shane mumford with extremely sticky jukes. If he's named sole ruck round 1 i'd be tempted to lock him in. Unfortunately Vickery void is what he is likely to fill

Nank has been going up against Maric in the match simulations, hasn't quite pushed his claims as yet. I like him as a prospect but I like Ryder's JS much more. At the moment it's Hampson vs Maric for the number one gig at Richmond. 

[Mongoose528]

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

[GCSkiwi]

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

Definitely Adams, definitely not Montagna, I would probably take Rance over Laird but either is a good pick.

Thanks for the discussion on Nank/Ryder guys :)

[gloryboy]

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

all great picks, hard to separate.  All priced about right too.  I'm personally not a fan of KPPs so Rance is out for me.

For me
Adams D2
Laird is safe pick.  Montagna likely to average more, but older so could miss games.  Laird has R13 bye (Montagna R11) which is better for starting players, but depends who your D1 is.
Laird D3 just

[Mongoose528]

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

all great picks, hard to separate.  All priced about right too.  I'm personally not a fan of KPPs so Rance is out for me.

For me
Adams D2
Laird is safe pick.  Montagna likely to average more, but older so could miss games.  Laird has R13 bye (Montagna R11) which is better for starting players, but depends who your D1 is.
Laird D3 just

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

Definitely Adams, definitely not Montagna, I would probably take Rance over Laird but either is a good pick.

Ah great, thanks for your opinions. I've gone for Adams and Laird.

[LordSneeze]

Laird v Montagna v Rance v Adams pick 2 as D2, D3

Its Laird and Rance from those for me.

Adams I have all but written off due to his upside not outweighing his injury history. Worst case scenario is he averages 100 to start the year without injury and I bring him in as one of my upgrades.
Ive been burnt too many times with injuries to be confident picking him

[Mantis]

I tend to avoid KP defenders, I like laird out of those also. Although have had all 3 of laird Adams and Montagna at some stage.

If you do look at Adams as an upgrade target and then trade him in and he gets injured your essentially burning 2 trades. I also am looking at trying to limit my injury prone players but think Adams will have one of the better ceilings in defense so will start him, same reason il start rockliff.

Some opinions on this would be appreciated I tend to be a guns n rookie supercoacher but do see some value in a couple of mid pricers.

Montagna Jelwood Sloane Rookie Rookie
Vs
Rookie Dangerfield Beams Murphy Swallow

Current backline is Shaw Adams Laird
Current mids Pendlebury Rocky JPK Fyfe