Player X v Player Y

[Hawker_08]

TMac vs Hodge

Cheers

[crowls]

TMac vs Hodge

Cheers

TMac,   expect Hodge to be a bit player all over the field this year.    Plus his style of game will slow down quicker than a Sam M or Boomer.    More downside risk with Hodge.   TMac is a chance to increase his consistency (for a KPP) and I expecting 92-98 avg from him.

[blackrose]

Hartlett + Docherty vs Taylor Adams + Johanissen

[TomK]

Hartlett + Docherty vs Taylor Adams + Johanissen

Adams and Johannisen

[crowls]

Hartlett + Docherty vs Taylor Adams + Johanissen

Adams and Johannisen

Leaning the other way.   Figure Doc is a 105+110 option, Johanissen is 92-98 option, Adams is a query.   So comes down to Hartlett +10-13 pts over Adams.   

[LordSneeze]

Hartlett + Docherty vs Taylor Adams + Johanissen

Adams and Johannisen

Leaning the other way.   Figure Doc is a 105+110 option, Johanissen is 92-98 option, Adams is a query.   So comes down to Hartlett +10-13 pts over Adams.   

Docherty has had 1 solid year and 1 good year. He increased his output to a level that is the envy of most defenders being top 3 in most stats, but I have a few question marks on him this year
1: What is the impact of Tuohy leaving given he was also a top 12 rebounding defender - Will this result in Simpson moving back from the wing into the rebounding role? How could this impact Docherty's possession and distribution numbers?
2: Where is the improvement - Arguably you could say he could increase his possession numbers further, but doing this will likely result in a drop in some of his other stats.

If im going to be paying for a player at that price I want to be able to be certain of his output. Id be happy to say I believe he will be around 100 and a top 6 defender, but there is some possibility that the he will drop towards more of the 95 mark.
For $591k you are able to pick Sloane, Cripps, Gray, Sidebottom, Ward, Fyfe and numerous more that already have years of runs on the board or a lot more upside

[tommy10]

Danger and Grundy vs Pendles and Goldy?

[Money Shot]

Danger and Grundy vs Pendles and Goldy?

Probably one of the tougher ones I've seen but you've got to go Pendles and Goldy as they are both going to be top 2 (you would think) in there position come seasons end.

Grundy is a bit of a risk compared to the other two.

[Peter]

Have a look at North's opening 8-10 rounds and Goldstein will go well - remember they started well last season too

[Hawker_08]

NRoo + Bont vs Macrea + Sloane (Don't want to pick 3 dogs prems)
Cheers

[crowls]

nroo and bont.       bont is a better vc option  and he looks like another pendlebuty in the making.     

[tommy10]

Hibberd vs Hartlett vs Biggs?

[tommy10]

Another one...

Docherty and Hartlett/Hibberd/Biggs vs Rance and JJ/Vince?

[GoLions]

NRoo + Bont vs Macrea + Sloane (Don't want to pick 3 dogs prems)
Cheers

Macrae and Sloane. Macrae should be less of a risk than nroo and score similar, and Sloaney is just awesome

[GoLions]

Hibberd vs Hartlett vs Biggs?

Probably Hibberd for me there