Player X v Player Y

[tommy10]

Laird for me too. Looks to spend more time in the midfield from reports and could average 105 ppg as a result.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

I tend to avoid KP defenders, I like laird out of those also. Although have had all 3 of laird Adams and Montagna at some stage.

If you do look at Adams as an upgrade target and then trade him in and he gets injured your essentially burning 2 trades. I also am looking at trying to limit my injury prone players but think Adams will have one of the better ceilings in defense so will start him, same reason il start rockliff.

Some opinions on this would be appreciated I tend to be a guns n rookie supercoacher but do see some value in a couple of mid pricers.

Montagna Jelwood Sloane Rookie Rookie
Vs
Rookie Dangerfield Beams Murphy Swallow

Current backline is Shaw Adams Laird
Current mids Pendlebury Rocky JPK Fyfe

:)

The true answer to this question really relies on what number of rookies come up on selection night. But to discount that and just look at the players mentioned.
Option 1   =  1 probable keeper in Montagna, 2 prems
Option 2.  =  1 elite prem, 1 possible prem (injury prone), 1 golden goose.

Option 1 for me, cheers mate.

Unsure on this one, even using the rationalization of the above, but

Hannerbury + Petrevski-Seton    v    Beams + Bennell H   This one on the assumption that both Beams and Bennell pull up ok after the preseason games and are selected Rd.1          :-\

[Hawker_08]

I tend to avoid KP defenders, I like laird out of those also. Although have had all 3 of laird Adams and Montagna at some stage.

If you do look at Adams as an upgrade target and then trade him in and he gets injured your essentially burning 2 trades. I also am looking at trying to limit my injury prone players but think Adams will have one of the better ceilings in defense so will start him, same reason il start rockliff.

Some opinions on this would be appreciated I tend to be a guns n rookie supercoacher but do see some value in a couple of mid pricers.

Montagna Jelwood Sloane Rookie Rookie
Vs
Rookie Dangerfield Beams Murphy Swallow

Current backline is Shaw Adams Laird
Current mids Pendlebury Rocky JPK Fyfe

:)

The true answer to this question really relies on what number of rookies come up on selection night. But to discount that and just look at the players mentioned.
Option 1   =  1 probable keeper in Montagna, 2 prems
Option 2.  =  1 elite prem, 1 possible prem (injury prone), 1 golden goose.

Option 1 for me, cheers mate.

Unsure on this one, even using the rationalization of the above, but

Hannerbury + Petrevski-Seton    v    Beams + Bennell H   This one on the assumption that both Beams and Bennell pull up ok after the preseason games and are selected Rd.1          :-\

I would have to go with Option 2 in Danger Beams Murphy Swallow and Rookie. Just can't see anyone making the points up if Danger starts well. And I would go Beams and Bennell. Yes there is more risk but Beams can match Hanners (maybe 5ppg less) if he gets going and Bennell is a potential keeper if all goes well + you save a couple of trades. On the downside, you could end up using more trades sidewaysing Beams and Bennell and then more upgrading to the super prems like hanners. Tough one!

[uncleswagy]

Grundy and docherty vs gawn and JJ?

[gloryboy]

Grundy and docherty vs gawn and JJ?

Goldy and doch!

[Hawker_08]

Goldy + McGrath vs Sandi + Laird

[GoLions]

Grundy and docherty vs gawn and JJ?

Goldy and doch!

He probably already has Goldy ;)

Gawn and JJ easily though^^

[uncleswagy]

Grundy and docherty vs gawn and JJ?

Goldy and doch!

He probably already has Goldy ;)

Gawn and JJ easily though^^

do alredy have goldy haha

[gloryboy]

Grundy and docherty vs gawn and JJ?

Goldy and doch!

He probably already has Goldy ;)

Gawn and JJ easily though^^

do alredy have goldy haha

Gawn and JJ then:)

[gloryboy]

Goldy + McGrath vs Sandi + Laird

Sandi and Laird

[Hoggyz_a_legend]

Goldy + McGrath vs Sandi + Laird

Sandi and Laird

Goldy 115 + McGrath 75 v Sandi 100 + Laird 100. Sandi and Laird for mine.


Ablett M3 + D.Swallow M7 + Sandi v Beams M6 + M11 + Goldy

[Mongoose528]

Goldy + McGrath vs Sandi + Laird

Sandi and Laird

Goldy 115 + McGrath 75 v Sandi 100 + Laird 100. Sandi and Laird for mine.


Ablett M3 + D.Swallow M7 + Sandi v Beams M6 + M11 + Goldy

Beams + Goldy + M11 imo

[eaglesman]

Docherty swallow goldy

Vs

TMAC ablett sandi

[gloryboy]

Docherty swallow goldy

Vs

TMAC ablett sandi

is that a serious question? lol
Doch Swallow Goldy 10 times over versus a risk risk risk

[gloryboy]

Gawn Goldy 300-350k player or rookie
v
Gawn Sandi Selwood

300-350k player can't be Swallow