Player X v Player Y

[Keeper27]

Laird/Rance + Taranto vs. Thurlow + JKelly

[TomK]

Laird/Rance + Taranto vs. Thurlow + JKelly

Laird and Taranto by a mile

[Gandalf123]

have to start one of Eddy/Butler/Houston  - leaning towards eddy, who would you pick?

[Rusty00]

have to start one of Eddy/Butler/Houston  - leaning towards eddy, who would you pick?

Eddy will only score well when kicking a few goals which I can't see him doing against the Swans, especially considering Sydney's weather lately. For these reasons I would probably also lean to Butler over Houston.

[JMAN23]

Roughy, Neale and Marchbank     or     Buddy, Titch and EVW/Hibberd 

[ants]

Roughy, Neale and Marchbank     or     Buddy, Titch and EVW/Hibberd 

thats a toss of the coin 90 110 75 vs 100 110 65

[john23132]

Jake Lloyd or Howe?

[Bully]

Jake Lloyd or Howe?

Howe

[rocky38]

Grundy at R1 with Nank at F3 or Riewoldt at F1 with Nank at R1

(Sandy second ruck)

[whynot102]

Goldy/Taranto or Witts/Selwood

[Bully]

Grundy at R1 with Nank at F3 or Riewoldt at F1 with Nank at R1

(Sandy second ruck)

Riewoldt option

[Bully]

Goldy/Taranto or Witts/Selwood

Witts & Selwood (but I prefer Treloar given Selwood plays a stack of away games to start the year).

[Gandalf123]

one last one that has been frying my brain - nervous about the fwd rooks but also uncertain about the rance v Lloyd part..

Rance and Buttler Vs Lloyd and Taranto

[madskill55]

* More of a SC Draft comparison but….

James Kelly Vs Andrew Mackie.

Unsure if Kelly will score well with everyone else back in Ess team & unsure how well Mackie will do.

[whynot102]

Already have Treloar maybe Hanners

Goldy/Taranto or Witts/Selwood

Witts & Selwood (but I prefer Treloar given Selwood plays a stack of away games to start the year).