Player X v Player Y

[billnats]

Goldy & D. Swallow
Or
Jacobs & T. Phillips

Goldy & D. Swallow easily

Ok so I'm keeping Swallow.
Ive had Kelly this whole time because I'm thinking it's his breakout year. But now I'm rethinking:

Goldy + Kelly
Or
Jacobs + Rocky/Treleor

[uncleswagy]

Goldy & D. Swallow
Or
Jacobs & T. Phillips

Goldy & D. Swallow easily

Ok so I'm keeping Swallow.
Ive had Kelly this whole time because I'm thinking it's his breakout year. But now I'm rethinking:

Goldy + Kelly
Or
Jacobs + Rocky/Treleor

Id say goldy and kelly purely based on the thought that i think Sauce is past it now

[crowls]

Hello peeps. Good to be back for season 2017, and good luck to everyone. Assume most of us have been throwing some things around while the pre season games are going on, so one of them for me is which of these lower priced yet risky premiums to add to my side. Been going with Jobe since the start but Beamsy seems to be warming into it but comes with a huge injury risk hanging over his head, and a bit the same for Marc Murphy. Watson the more safer option but gee, Beams can go big if his fitness holds up so someone help. Only going one of these.

ps only just logged on for the first time this year so apologise if this has been discussed a thousand times.

see jobe as 100-105 scorer and beams 115+ scorer.     up to you if the risk is worth the extra points.   

I don't know if Jobe will go back to his 120+, supplement-aided best but I'd back him in to go better than 105. The dude is in excellent shape and has never had a better on-ball brigade around him.

I agree,  being fitter and leaner than past should see him perform at a high level.   I would be surprised if he went over 105 but great if he does as I am bomber supporter.   Won't be in my team though

[tommy10]

Macrae & Bowes vs Touk/Higgins & Swallow? Fighting for F2 & M8 respectively.

[Blues Blues Blues]

Macrae & Bowes vs Touk/Higgins & Swallow? Fighting for F2 & M8 respectively.

Higgins and Swallow. Not sure on Bowes at moment

[Blues Blues Blues]

Ok, I have 2 for feedback:

1. Treloar v Rocky

Treloar appears ready to explode, and whilst reports on Rocky suggest he looks fit I've been burnt before and I do worry about his glass ribs and jaw...

2. M.murphy, Macrae and Roughy v Titchell, Higgins and Steele

[Hawker_08]

I have a couple:

Rocky vs JPK vs Hanners (that is my order atm)

and

Greene/Caddy + Goldy vs NRoo + Grundy (currently have second option as I don't 100% trust greene/caddy)

Bump

[Hawka]

been dealing with this one for a few days
Shaw vs Docherty

Shaw is more trust worthy , but Doc has a chance to average more

[GoLions]

I have a couple:

Rocky vs JPK vs Hanners (that is my order atm)

and

Greene/Caddy + Goldy vs NRoo + Grundy (currently have second option as I don't 100% trust greene/caddy)

Bump

Rocky > JPK > Hanners

Caddy and Goldy

[GoLions]

Ok, I have 2 for feedback:

1. Treloar v Rocky

Treloar appears ready to explode, and whilst reports on Rocky suggest he looks fit I've been burnt before and I do worry about his glass ribs and jaw...

2. M.murphy, Macrae and Roughy v Titchell, Higgins and Steele

Rocky

Can you afford Titch, Higgins, Roughy? First option if not

[Bluesman]

JPK, Macrae & Hrovat    VS
Titch,  Caddy & Higgins?

[GoLions]

JPK, Macrae & Hrovat    VS
Titch,  Caddy & Higgins?

2nd option, as i don't really rate the hrovat pick

[Keeper27]

Touhy vs. Mills

[GoLions]

Touhy vs. Mills

Probably go for Mills, but tbh I wouldn't be confident in either if expecting 90+ averages

[crowls]

Ok, I have 2 for feedback:

1. Treloar v Rocky

Treloar appears ready to explode, and whilst reports on Rocky suggest he looks fit I've been burnt before and I do worry about his glass ribs and jaw...

2. M.murphy, Macrae and Roughy v Titchell, Higgins and Steele

Treloar, will continue to improve and lower risk of missing games.   Rocky may still out average him but Treloar will have more overall points at end of the year.


2.   Tough.   For me I would go Mitchell option as High prob mid prem who could make superprem,  Higgins I see having more opportunity at North and will improve again this year.   Steele could be good but I would have roughy.