Player X v Player Y

Started by _wato, January 06, 2017, 12:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

dylanclements

I didn't see Cousins but am looking at him over Bolton. Bolton is probably competing with Butler, Castagna, Lennon, Rioli, Lloyd, and to some extent even guys like Menadue. It's hard to know exactly how Dimma sees his ideal team but I think his direct competition in Rioli, Castagna, and Lloyd are a bit more advanced at this stage. Butler seemed to show enough to come back in pretty quickly, and Lennon will probably get a go soon too - rightly or wrongly I think Castagna and Bolton are the two most likely to get the chop. There'll be some shuffling among these guys all year I reckon

Hawka

Quote from: no eye deer on May 29, 2017, 05:37:20 PM
Bolton or Cousins a week early? Think I can only squeeze one in. Byes don't matter. Will Bolton keep his spot? Cousins apparently has ok JS. Hawks or Tigers supporters want to way in?
Cousins JS should be solid, played great on the weekend and i really think he has talent!

Judd Magic

Quote from: Hawka on May 30, 2017, 02:05:41 AM
Quote from: no eye deer on May 29, 2017, 05:37:20 PM
Bolton or Cousins a week early? Think I can only squeeze one in. Byes don't matter. Will Bolton keep his spot? Cousins apparently has ok JS. Hawks or Tigers supporters want to way in?
Cousins JS should be solid, played great on the weekend and i really think he has talent!

Cousins is a way better option than Bolton IMO.

Better JS and higher scoring potential.

no eye deer

Cheers for all the replies fellas. Cousins it is then.

Blues Blues Blues

Sloane ($586.8k and 49 BE) v Pendles ($560.1k and 57 BE) v Jelwood ($547.4k and 62 BE)

tor01doc

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on May 30, 2017, 08:18:40 PM
Sloane ($586.8k and 49 BE) v Pendles ($560.1k and 57 BE) v Jelwood ($547.4k and 62 BE)

Round 12 bye - Duckwood

Round 13 - Sloane and Pendles

Does that influence you?

I would rate them Sloane then Pendles then 'Free kick for' (check the stats before you argue)

Bully

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on May 30, 2017, 08:18:40 PM
Sloane ($586.8k and 49 BE) v Pendles ($560.1k and 57 BE) v Jelwood ($547.4k and 62 BE)

Impossible choice, can't go wrong with any. I'd probably go Selwood due to great bye, cheap price & heaps of home games.

tommy10

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on May 30, 2017, 08:18:40 PM
Sloane ($586.8k and 49 BE) v Pendles ($560.1k and 57 BE) v Jelwood ($547.4k and 62 BE)
Sloane, Pendles and Selwood in that order

Mark

Sloane or Dusty guys/girls ?

I like Sloane better but Dusty is playing Rd 13 when I need players..

I'm not going for overall just league overall

Huttabito

Quote from: Mark on May 30, 2017, 09:40:48 PM
Sloane or Dusty guys/girls ?

I like Sloane better but Dusty is playing Rd 13 when I need players..

I'm not going for overall just league overall
Sloane will net you more points in the long run, especially come the pointy/final end of the season.

Maca24


Bully

Quote from: Maca24 on May 30, 2017, 11:25:53 PM
Wines vs Gray

Wines for me, bringing him in myself. For reasoning & data, seems to have broken the 120+ ceiling this year, Port have a very nice run coming up which should give him a decent share of the midfield points, seems more durable than Gray & is currently 58k under his true value. Great player to eventually plonk at M9.

Marcon

Really struggling with who to ditch for Scooter Selwood, would love a bit of help!

The 3 options I have are SPP, Jake Barrett and Zac Fisher.

SPP: Held through his bye and should serve as cover over the next 3 weeks. However has maxed out on price.
Barrett: Has been a good scorer as of late and still has some cash to make. Has the bye this week.
Fisher: Scoring potential limited, also has the bye this week. Requires 80k to move up and may still have $$ to make

Thanks!

Ringo

I would go Fisher, Barrett and SPP in that order. Think Fisher will make less cash than Barrett and as you say with SPP he plays through byes. If concerned about SPP could go SPP to Cousins on the bubble in Rd 13.

Marcon

Quote from: Ringo on May 31, 2017, 04:36:36 PM
I would go Fisher, Barrett and SPP in that order. Think Fisher will make less cash than Barrett and as you say with SPP he plays through byes. If concerned about SPP could go SPP to Cousins on the bubble in Rd 13.


Thanks Ringo! That was my thinking as of right now. Will just have to fork out the 80k I think