Player X v Player Y

[GoLions]

Swallow to GHS or Swallow to Turner/McCarthy and Stef to Goldy?

[Mat0369]

I don't like GHS so the other one.

[GoLions]

I don't like GHS so the other one.

Yeah not too keen on him atm either. Other option is holding Swallow and banking ~80 from SPP as emg

[Mat0369]

The only downside to holding Swallow is what happens if he is injured longer then 1 week. You have to burn the trade later. I'd be tempted to grab Turner and Goldy and hope that Goldy outscores Stef more then SPP potentially outscores Turner. I'm thinking Turner will probably get a 50-60 based on the West Coast defense.

[mzunguman]

Why not GHS???

[TomK]

Guys, do I hold Swallow and get SPP's score? Or go to GHS or even Otten swinging Hibberd to the middle and pocket the 160k for any correction trades?

[TomK]

Guys, do I hold Swallow and get SPP's score? Or go to GHS or even Otten swinging Hibberd to the middle and pocket the 160k for any correction trades?

flower it, decided to hold

[Mat0369]

Why not GHS???

He will probably tag and he has been hyped up about almost every year and continued to suck every year. He isn't really good at all. You're better off banking the cash on someone else.

Guys, do I hold Swallow and get SPP's score? Or go to GHS or even Otten swinging Hibberd to the middle and pocket the 160k for any correction trades?

If you're willing to risk burning a trade later on if Swallow doesn't come back quickly then hold Swallow. I wouldn't bring in GHS though as stated above.

[Bluesman]

Option 1: JPK (110) + Zac Jones (80) + 45k (190 total pts)
Option 2: Titch (105-110)+ Zac Jones + 97k (185-195 pts)
Option 3: Clayton Oliver (90-100) + heath shaw (100-105) + 10k (190-205)
Option 4: Clayton Oliver + Zac Jones + 290k (170 pts)

In brackets is what i believe they might average this year. I know most will probably say option 1, 2 or 3 but I really rate Oliver this year. Considering this I may only be 30 pts down in points but what it does do is open up the opportunity for me to grab the right corrective trades.  El.  Bowes, JPK or Titch etc... depending on who is performing better. Cheers in anticipation!

Option 1, don't like the Oliver pick personally, and prefer JPK over Tmitch

Arguably BOG - 36 possies, 14 contested, 9 clearances and 8 tackes and how many SC points?? - that's right 109!!! what a load of BS!!! Yes I know he had 9 kicks and 27 handballs which doesn't help his cause but I'll say again...THIS KID'S THE NEXT PRIDDIS! haha..

[hawkboy80]

Guys, do I hold Swallow and get SPP's score? Or go to GHS or even Otten swinging Hibberd to the middle and pocket the 160k for any correction trades?

+1

[GoLions]

Cam McCarthy vs Kayne Turner vs any other forward or mid rookie under 224k that hasn't played yet (have Taranto, Simpkin, Parfitt already)

[Mat0369]

I had Kayne Turner most of the pre-season before I turned him into Houston today.

[GoLions]

I had Kayne Turner most of the pre-season before I turned him into Houston today.

I'm thinking Turner slightly better scoring but McCarthy better JS. But with Turner being cheaper as well...leaning towards him.

[Mat0369]

Where do you have Parfitt? Forward line or midfield?

[GoLions]

Where do you have Parfitt? Forward line or midfield?

Got him in the mids atm