Which Rucks?

[My Chumps]

Jake Spencer anyone?

[Holz]

Jake Spencer anyone?

Would go Witts over him every day of the week.

if you have witts either switch nank into the ruck and pick a premo mid or forward. If you dont have nank then pick up Brodie Grundy/ Stef Martin.

thats what i would do

[ben_020285]

Jake Spencer anyone?

If possible give him a couple of weeks until he is on the bubble.

Has the potential to be just as good an option as Witts, if not better as the Dees midfield is superior to the Suns.

When Spencer last played in 2015, he played four games as the sole ruck and averaged 94. He's a much better player than he was back then so he could turn out to be a great option.

[AN1611]

Is too late to get witts?
Currently have gawn, contemplating getting either Stefan or witts

[PICCOLLO]

Similar situation to a few it seems. Im not set on trading Goldy as Preuss was dropped for Round 2 only to come in when Goldy didnt get up.  That suggests Goldy is their no.1 when fit. 

Only issue is he isnt 100% and Preuss is taking his chance.

Goldy to Witts, Omeara to Sloane/Dusty

Or

Omeara to T.Miller to fill in my fwds a bit.

Tough call.  Never like trading premoes but it might be warranted here.  North are always shifty about injuries.

[enzedder]

Similar situation to a few it seems. Im not set on trading Goldy as Preuss was dropped for Round 2 only to come in when Goldy didnt get up.  That suggests Goldy is their no.1 when fit. 

Only issue is he isnt 100% and Preuss is taking his chance.

Goldy to Witts, Omeara to Sloane/Dusty

Or

Omeara to T.Miller to fill in my fwds a bit.

Tough call.  Never like trading premoes but it might be warranted here.  North are always shifty about injuries.

He who hesitates is lost.
I'm happy I traded Goldy out after R1 when there was speculation he would be a late out.
Grabbed Witts and I'm about 160 points up on the deal with Witts going great guns and finances heading in the right direction.
Both trades above look very good to me.

[Ringo]

Just advising those with Witts - Nicholls will probably return from injury this weekend possibly via NEAFL so we ait to see what happens.

[RaisyDaisy]

Just advising those with Witts - Nicholls will probably return from injury this weekend possibly via NEAFL so we ait to see what happens.

No chance of taking Witts spot based on current form. Just keep doing what you're doing Witts!

[LordSneeze]

Just advising those with Witts - Nicholls will probably return from injury this weekend possibly via NEAFL so we ait to see what happens.

Even if Nicholls comes back in and Witts drops off those who started Witts will have made enough cash to have made it worth while.
IMO Witts has done more than enough to hold his spot as a sole ruck.

[Ringo]

I agree with you both and just giving the update so coaches are made aware.

[Ricochet]

Just advising those with Witts - Nicholls will probably return from injury this weekend possibly via NEAFL so we ait to see what happens.

Even if Nicholls comes back in and Witts drops off those who started Witts will have made enough cash to have made it worth while.
IMO Witts has done more than enough to hold his spot as a sole ruck.

Yep I'd be looking at Stef or Grundy.

[Holz]

Similar situation to a few it seems. Im not set on trading Goldy as Preuss was dropped for Round 2 only to come in when Goldy didnt get up.  That suggests Goldy is their no.1 when fit. 

Only issue is he isnt 100% and Preuss is taking his chance.

Goldy to Witts, Omeara to Sloane/Dusty

Or

Omeara to T.Miller to fill in my fwds a bit.

Tough call.  Never like trading premoes but it might be warranted here.  North are always shifty about injuries.

im looking at the same, im backing in goldy for 1 more week.

Omeara + Spud to T.Miller and Newman just looks better for cash generation. If goldy spuds it up again then take the hit next week.

[frenzy]

Majak Daw available this week, Mason Wood back in VFL this week, Jarred Waite returning early next week. Kangas can't play them all.

Goldy, Preuss, Brown, Wood, Waite, Daw, Flower me, that's alot of talls to pick from.

[Holz]

Majak Daw available this week, Mason Wood back in VFL this week, Jarred Waite returning early next week. Kangas can't play them all.

Goldy, Preuss, Brown, Wood, Waite, Daw, Flower me, that's alot of talls to pick from.

its why im holding.

I reckon Daw wont be back this week though.

my prediction is Goldy plays more ruck then Preuss this week with preuss playing forward. Then when Daw and Wood coming back some big moves will be made.

We cant possibly see Goldy getting dropped can we?

Mason Wood if healthy i dont see getting held out for preuss. Preuss is our future ruck but Wood is our future Forward.

[shaker]

Majak Daw available this week, Mason Wood back in VFL this week, Jarred Waite returning early next week. Kangas can't play them all.

Goldy, Preuss, Brown, Wood, Waite, Daw, Flower me, that's alot of talls to pick from.

its why im holding.

I reckon Daw wont be back this week though.

my prediction is Goldy plays more ruck then Preuss this week with preuss playing forward. Then when Daw and Wood coming back some big moves will be made.

We cant possibly see Goldy getting dropped can we?

Mason Wood if healthy i dont see getting held out for preuss. Preuss is our future ruck but Wood is our future Forward.

Maybe your right Goldy was played FWD last week and had little affect Preuss hit the scoreboard more playing more ruck
the coach might reverse it this week so Goldy would want to perform and if Preuss plays well when rucking and kicks 3 or 4 goals when forward Goldy might be in trouble interesting to see what unfolds