Main Menu

Which Rucks?

Started by RaisyDaisy, December 12, 2016, 12:27:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

shaker

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on February 26, 2017, 08:18:43 PM
Quote from: shaker on February 26, 2017, 07:54:10 PM
If Preuss lines up R1 then no Goldy

I would have thought having the cover was good. Daw, Brown and Petrie etc haven't impacted Goldy's scoring so will Preuss really impact that much?

I've never had Goldy so not really impacting me but those that do have him I guess I'm curious to see how it plays at

Still have not really decided R2 but if Preuss lines up then Grundy looks the go for me maybe Preuss R3 see how things pan out I guess but it would have to some affect on Goldy's scoring

Holz

Goldy put up a good score with him in the team.

Goldy is the ruck but we saw he can kick a few goals to compensate not being in the ruck. Remember his 170 game against gawn

crowls

Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 08:57:42 PM
Goldy put up a good score with him in the team.

Goldy is the ruck but we saw he can kick a few goals to compensate not being in the ruck. Remember his 170 game against gawn
Big risk taking goldy if Pruess is going to get a consistent game.    Looks like great back up for goldy and north.   Not so good for SC.     Hard to see Goldy maintaining a 100+ avg with Pruess playing every game.   Will be sticking with my Gawndilandsstryndica

shaker

Even starting Preuss at R3 if he starts R1 if he gets dropped 2 or 3 games in you are stuck with non DPP  :-\ think I will just forget about it till before R1

Holz

Quote from: crowls on February 26, 2017, 09:14:05 PM
Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 08:57:42 PM
Goldy put up a good score with him in the team.

Goldy is the ruck but we saw he can kick a few goals to compensate not being in the ruck. Remember his 170 game against gawn
Big risk taking goldy if Pruess is going to get a consistent game.    Looks like great back up for goldy and north.   Not so good for SC.     Hard to see Goldy maintaining a 100+ avg with Pruess playing every game.   Will be sticking with my Gawndilandsstryndica

Goldy preuss daw wood waite brown cant play in the same squad. Preuss only getting games as others are injured.

As shaker has said he might get dropped early even if he does plays. However in response to that he will play if goldy misses

Bully

Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 10:26:42 PM
Quote from: crowls on February 26, 2017, 09:14:05 PM
Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 08:57:42 PM
Goldy put up a good score with him in the team.

Goldy is the ruck but we saw he can kick a few goals to compensate not being in the ruck. Remember his 170 game against gawn
Big risk taking goldy if Pruess is going to get a consistent game.    Looks like great back up for goldy and north.   Not so good for SC.     Hard to see Goldy maintaining a 100+ avg with Pruess playing every game.   Will be sticking with my Gawndilandsstryndica

Goldy preuss daw wood waite brown cant play in the same squad. Preuss only getting games as others are injured.

As shaker has said he might get dropped early even if he does plays. However in response to that he will play if goldy misses

He's good back-up for Goldy but not necessarily for Gawn, this is where the plan could unravel.

meow meow

I'm thinking a Preuss, Cameron - Korcheck (will be #1 (only ruck left) at Carlton in about 3 weeks) combo is the way to go. Allows me to have Dangerfield at M8

jfitty

Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 10:26:42 PM
Quote from: crowls on February 26, 2017, 09:14:05 PM
Quote from: Holz on February 26, 2017, 08:57:42 PM
Goldy put up a good score with him in the team.

Goldy is the ruck but we saw he can kick a few goals to compensate not being in the ruck. Remember his 170 game against gawn
Big risk taking goldy if Pruess is going to get a consistent game.    Looks like great back up for goldy and north.   Not so good for SC.     Hard to see Goldy maintaining a 100+ avg with Pruess playing every game.   Will be sticking with my Gawndilandsstryndica

Goldy preuss daw wood waite brown cant play in the same squad. Preuss only getting games as others are injured.

As shaker has said he might get dropped early even if he does plays. However in response to that he will play if goldy misses

This is what it comes down to for me - I can't see Preuss playing when both Daw and Brown are fit.. Especially not when you have an elite first ruckman.

Unless North has plans to rotate one of the rucks forward now that Wood is going to miss games, but add Waite into the mix and it's a pretty top-heavy forward line.

I've had Goldstein locked into my team for most of the preseason, but thinking I might wait and see how that all plays out.

Holz

Do find it funny that a guy scored 94 from 65% game time and then people seem in a rush to trade him out.

what more do you want from him?


Money Shot

Quote from: Holz on February 27, 2017, 12:49:35 PM
Do find it funny that a guy scored 94 from 65% game time and then people seem in a rush to trade him out.

what more do you want from him?
I was hoping he would only play 50% and score 60 or so and everyone would trade him out so he can be a pod.

frenzy

Quote from: meow meow on February 26, 2017, 11:40:03 PM
I'm thinking a Preuss, Cameron - Korcheck (will be #1 (only ruck left) at Carlton in about 3 weeks) combo is the way to go. Allows me to have Dangerfield at M8

^ Lol :o

Judd Magic

Is going Grundy and Sandi as my rucks and not having Gawn a dumb idea?

My team looks way more balanced by downgrading Gawn to Grundy.

Can upgrade Sandi to Gawn when his price drops a bit.

AaronKirk

Unless you believe Preuss is going to consistently play when Brown is fit then I wouldn't pick him.

I can see Daw and Preuss interchanging between the VFL and Senior sides most of the season.

Darcy Cameron seems to be the likely playing DPP option. If he plays round 1 I am inclined to pick him. Otherwise I will stick with an Floating Donut in Strndica.

I have abandoned the Witts R3 option.

Still at this stage going with Gawn and Sandi but if some mid rookies bob up I may just lock in Gawn and Goldy.

crowls

Quote from: AaronKirk on March 01, 2017, 03:05:12 AM
Unless you believe Preuss is going to consistently play when Brown is fit then I wouldn't pick him.

I can see Daw and Preuss interchanging between the VFL and Senior sides most of the season.

Darcy Cameron seems to be the likely playing DPP option. If he plays round 1 I am inclined to pick him. Otherwise I will stick with an Floating Donut in Strndica.

I have abandoned the Witts R3 option.

Still at this stage going with Gawn and Sandi but if some mid rookies bob up I may just lock in Gawn and Goldy.
pretty much same resolution for me AK.    Currently have Strndica r3 and Cameron f7.   Extra cash from Sandi selection gives flexibility to juggle rest of my lines.    If I have to go Goldy Gawn then some of good value injury players come into my team.    Roughy, Beams, JOM and Swallow, Murphy

dottman

I'm thinking of ordering the "CURRIE" might end up with the sh!ts, but you never know if you don't try it.