Roughead

[Ringo]

I am worried about Roughy as well contemplating Roughy to Steele as I already have WHE.

[HoleMeal]

I went to todays game and barrack for another team so have no interest other than SC.

Watched Roughy the ENTIRE game.

Next week will be Roughy to WHE 110% locked.

He looked ok in the 1st quarter. Lethargic and blowing hard in the 2nd. In the 3rd he took a couple of marks and kicked 2.2 by games end.

Bottom line is that for him to be back is a massive effort coming from what he went through. Secondly, the Hawks are DEFINITELY not what they used to be. Maybe will be top 6, but are not clinical. They have 4 players that would not have got a game 2 years ago.

It;s my 2 cents worth but thats my take on today.

[Bully]

I went to todays game and barrack for another team so have no interest other than SC.

Watched Roughy the ENTIRE game.

Next week will be Roughy to WHE 110% locked.

He looked ok in the 1st quarter. Lethargic and blowing hard in the 2nd. In the 3rd he took a couple of marks and kicked 2.2 by games end.

Bottom line is that for him to be back is a massive effort coming from what he went through. Secondly, the Hawks are DEFINITELY not what they used to be. Maybe will be top 6, but are not clinical. They have 4 players that would not have got a game 2 years ago.

It;s my 2 cents worth but thats my take on today.

Thanks for the heads up, made my decision a little easier.

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah Rough to WHE pretty much locked

Now what to do with the 235k I'll have in the bank and the 2nd trade....

Probably Eddy to Butler/Hannan for now

[AaronKirk]

Gold Coast are arguably the worst form team in the comp based on their first 6 quarters of footy this season. I would recommend restraint and hold Roughead for now.

He has a great chance for a field day next weekend.

[Bully]

Yeah Rough to WHE pretty much locked

Now what to do with the 235k I'll have in the bank and the 2nd trade....

Probably Eddy to Butler/Hannan for now

Have a number of different options, could go Swallow to Murphy dependent on form this week.

[whynot102]

Next week GHS to Murphy

[WizzFizz]

Gold Coast are arguably the worst form team in the comp based on their first 6 quarters of footy this season. I would recommend restraint and hold Roughead for now.

He has a great chance for a field day next weekend.

^ this

he is capable of 7 goals and 170+. I dont see why you would trade him after 2 average games. He is a kpp remember

[MontyJnr]

LOL MS 70-75? I'll take that bet

His first game in 12+ months scoring 63 who cares

Came out with a 95 the next game

As for the 76, his DE was incredibly low which isn't the norm for him, and he had something like 6 clangers too. I was actually impressed that he scored 76 based off how bad his stats where, so that's only encouraging imo

90+ is the pass mark for a prem forward this year, and he can hit that

Still locked

Wish you didn't talk me into starting him ;) Ah well, he hasn't worked out and will look to move him on as soon as lockout ends

[RaisyDaisy]

LOL MS 70-75? I'll take that bet

His first game in 12+ months scoring 63 who cares

Came out with a 95 the next game

As for the 76, his DE was incredibly low which isn't the norm for him, and he had something like 6 clangers too. I was actually impressed that he scored 76 based off how bad his stats where, so that's only encouraging imo

90+ is the pass mark for a prem forward this year, and he can hit that

Still locked

Wish you didn't talk me into starting him ;) Ah well, he hasn't worked out and will look to move him on as soon as lockout ends

Ha, yeah that's pretty much it. Hasn't worked out so happy to move on quickly instead of giving chance after chance only to fall behind. He still looks pretty good out on the field, but the Hawks are clearly not the dominant side we've come to expect so with more losses that naturally reduces his scoring potential

[Samsturmfels]

Roughy to Nank next week

[Judd Magic]

Glad I avoided starting with Roughead.  ;)

Don't have to waste a trade there.  8)

Might bring in Witts though for Taranto and move Nank back down forward.  :)

[Mat0369]

I avoided Roughy, I didn't avoid Steele though.

[Judd Magic]

I avoided Roughy, I didn't avoid Steele though.

[piesfan1989]

Roughy seems to be scoring pretty well from not doing all that much...imagine what will happen when he kicks 5 in a hawthorn win