The Playing Rookies Thread 2017 Edition

[RaisyDaisy]

Whats wrong with McInnes RD they got flogged today and there seems to be a few backmen that got out performed by him ?

He's in the side purely as a second ruck

Petrie and Lycett are very close, and Giles could return too

I cannot see how McInnes holds down a spot much longer

[AaronKirk]

Whats wrong with McInnes RD they got flogged today and there seems to be a few backmen that got out performed by him ?

He's in the side purely as a second ruck

Petrie and Lycett are very close, and Giles could return too

I cannot see how McInnes holds down a spot much longer

Plenty of passengers in the West Coast side today but he wasn't one of them. I went a week early on him and he looks fine to stay in the side for a while.

[shaker]

Whats wrong with McInnes RD they got flogged today and there seems to be a few backmen that got out performed by him ?

He's in the side purely as a second ruck

Petrie and Lycett are very close, and Giles could return too

I cannot see how McInnes holds down a spot much longer

Cheers was thinking about getting him maybe not

[sammy123]

Whats wrong with McInnes RD they got flogged today and there seems to be a few backmen that got out performed by him ?

He's in the side purely as a second ruck

Petrie and Lycett are very close, and Giles could return too

I cannot see how McInnes holds down a spot much longer

Cheers was thinking about getting him maybe not

if he stayed in the side it would be great. i need a defensive rookie

[Mat0369]

Petrie isn't coming back. If he does West Coast are tanking. Giles isn't much better but considering neither of Vardy or McInnes could break even with Leuenberger he at least gives them some height to cause a 50/50 compared to a direct hit to advantage. What might save both is the fact they have GWS at Domain next week. Lobb is injured and Mummy could be rubbed out. I'd play both again and hope they beat the opposition spud at ground level like they did last week against Boyd.

[Gigantor]

Marchbanks BE will be 97

Time to go especially if you are already losing money on Otten and Hampton

[Hawka]

Marchbanks BE will be 97

Time to go especially if you are already losing money on Otten and Hampton

Met his BE this week thats all i needed now time to get my last defense upgrade!

[LF]

Just for those thinking of grabbing McInnes
He was upgraded for Lycett who is due back in a couple of weeks

Patrick Keane @AFL_PKeane
West Coast has upgraded Fraser McInnes from the rookie list to replace Scott Lycett, who was already on the long-term injury list.

[Bully]

Just for those thinking of grabbing McInnes
He was upgraded for Lycett who is due back in a couple of weeks

Patrick Keane @AFL_PKeane
West Coast has upgraded Fraser McInnes from the rookie list to replace Scott Lycett, who was already on the long-term injury list.

Would just need him for the byes and then can cash in.

[MontyJnr]

Whats wrong with McInnes RD they got flogged today and there seems to be a few backmen that got out performed by him ?

He's in the side purely as a second ruck

Petrie and Lycett are very close, and Giles could return too

I cannot see how McInnes holds down a spot much longer

Come on, lets be real here. Surely Drew Petrie isn't threatening anyone's position? He's completely past it.

[RaisyDaisy]

Just for those thinking of grabbing McInnes
He was upgraded for Lycett who is due back in a couple of weeks

Patrick Keane @AFL_PKeane
West Coast has upgraded Fraser McInnes from the rookie list to replace Scott Lycett, who was already on the long-term injury list.

Would just need him for the byes and then can cash in.

Might get Round 11, then he has the bye Round 12 and then I doubt he comes back as Lycett is due then

So you get the next 2 weeks...

As for the people talking down Petrie, I agree he isn't great but don't be fooled - Simmo started him and only injury kept him out. I won't be surprised to see him back

I get it, we want a def rookie option but McInnes and O'Connor are not that answers in my opinion

I've said enough, so do whatever you want

[Hawka]

Just for those thinking of grabbing McInnes
He was upgraded for Lycett who is due back in a couple of weeks

Patrick Keane @AFL_PKeane
West Coast has upgraded Fraser McInnes from the rookie list to replace Scott Lycett, who was already on the long-term injury list.

Would just need him for the byes and then can cash in.

Pray for Mcniece again ? haha

Might get Round 11, then he has the bye Round 12 and then I doubt he comes back as Lycett is due then

So you get the next 2 weeks...

As for the people talking down Petrie, I agree he isn't great but don't be fooled - Simmo started him and only injury kept him out. I won't be surprised to see him back

I get it, we want a def rookie option but McInnes and O'Connor are not that answers in my opinion

I've said enough, so do whatever you want

[RaisyDaisy]

Perryman at 153k is who I'm looking at for a def rookie

DEF/MID DPP could be super handy too, not to mention GWS have injuries

[LF]

Just for those thinking of grabbing McInnes
He was upgraded for Lycett who is due back in a couple of weeks

Patrick Keane @AFL_PKeane
West Coast has upgraded Fraser McInnes from the rookie list to replace Scott Lycett, who was already on the long-term injury list.

Would just need him for the byes and then can cash in.

Might get Round 11, then he has the bye Round 12 and then I doubt he comes back as Lycett is due then

So you get the next 2 weeks...

As for the people talking down Petrie, I agree he isn't great but don't be fooled - Simmo started him and only injury kept him out. I won't be surprised to see him back

I get it, we want a def rookie option but McInnes and O'Connor are not that answers in my opinion

I've said enough, so do whatever you want

Petrie did alright in the WAFL yesterday as well

Also keep your eyes out for Rioli,he played reserves yesterday,kicked 4 goals and didn't do too bad

[Bully]

Perryman at 153k is who I'm looking at for a def rookie

DEF/MID DPP could be super handy too, not to mention GWS have injuries

Could be the answer.