The Playing Rookies Thread 2017 Edition

[Mat0369]

Pick one to keep out of Pickett and Parfitt. Both are sucking.

[Judd Magic]

Pick one to keep out of Pickett and Parfitt. Both are sucking.

I'd turf Pickett as he looks the most useless out of the 2 IMO.

[Mat0369]

I'd turf Pickett as he looks the most useless out of the 2 IMO.

I dunno, Parfitt is pretty useless as well.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'd turf Pickett as he looks the most useless out of the 2 IMO.

I dunno, Parfitt is pretty useless as well.

Pickett BE 8
Parfitt BE -13

Get rid of Pickett

[Colliwobblers]

maybe go with job security, pickett ws more promising today.... just...

[Mat0369]

The fact that Parfitt went at 50 DT for 36 SC is a bit of a worry. Pickett does something when he gets the ball, he just doesn't get the ball.

[TomK]

Pick one to keep out of Pickett and Parfitt. Both are sucking.

I have the same decision, turfed Pickett atm due to BE but not sure yet

[Colliwobblers]

pickett was 49 DT/AF to 35 SC this week also.....

tough question you ask...

flip a coin,

[piesfan1989]

How come you guys are trading one of parfitt/pickett out? Are your teams that perfect or are you not liking their cash generation prospects? Do you have any actual replacements that you didn't already have? I assume everyone has SPP & barrett?

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm keeping both

I'll get more points/cash from doing Florent to Murphy  8)

[RaisyDaisy]

How come you guys are trading one of parfitt/pickett out? Are your teams that perfect or are you not liking their cash generation prospects? Do you have any actual replacements that you didn't already have? I assume everyone has SPP & barrett?

Because their scoring like shower and Butler/Houston are scoring better

This is the week to get the rookies you want

[Mat0369]

How come you guys are trading one of parfitt/pickett out? Are your teams that perfect or are you not liking their cash generation prospects? Do you have any actual replacements that you didn't already have? I assume everyone has SPP & barrett?

I have a few options. I have no Butler and could play Taranto at M8 with SPS on the bench (SPP M7).

I have Cameron at R3 so I could grab Witts who looks to spike in price and will bring me more cash. Considering people copped the Goldy 0 this week and my R1 in Gawn has been banged up it is logical to bring in a playing rookie at R3.

Someone like Turner will give me more in terms of cash then the spud 35-40 these guys are giving me. It's fair enough having 1 slow burner at M11, I don't think you can afford to carry 2.

[piesfan1989]

How come you guys are trading one of parfitt/pickett out? Are your teams that perfect or are you not liking their cash generation prospects? Do you have any actual replacements that you didn't already have? I assume everyone has SPP & barrett?

Because their scoring like shower and Butler/Houston are scoring better

This is the week to get the rookies you want

Apologies...I thought they were being traded out of the mids, which is where I have them. There seems to be 0 decent midfield scoring rookies

[Colliwobblers]

i didnt start will hoskin so got him in, and i didnt have preuss so i got him in, dont like the trades this early but those two set to make a LOT of money so i think had to be done. 2 trades down, ill be keeping pickett and dont have parfitt, but i have other NM spud rooks dropped this week and they will just have to stay there like it or not.

[Mat0369]

I started with Hoskin-Elliott and Houston so I at least got two right. I also slotted Macreadie into D8 and ran with Hibberd in the mids which looks like a good call. It allowed me to bail on Hibberd already (Hannan sucked this week though) and give me a couple of options this week.