The Playing Rookies Thread 2017 Edition

[GCSkiwi]

JOEL SMITH!

Do we pick him?

What role does he play? Hibberd due to come back (know next to nothing about Dees :P)

[RaisyDaisy]

Not changing my structure now

Otten, Hibberd and Stewart down back. Will only pick Smith if one of those 3 don't make it

Smith must have dicey JS and is every chance to get dropped within weeks, so D8 at best but I'm hoping the other 3 get up so I can avoid Smith

SPP, Barrett and Parfitt/DPP at M11

Pickett and Eddy up front

Passing on Butler, Mountford etc etc

[batt]

Smith > Otten imo.

[_wato]

Same as you RD

however only 2 of Otten Stewart Hibberd

Same mids

Same ruck

Same fwd rookies

You have Taranto I'm assuming?

[Torpedo10]

Not changing my structure now

Otten, Hibberd and Stewart down back. Will only pick Smith if one of those 3 don't make it

Smith must have dicey JS and is every chance to get dropped within weeks, so D8 at best but I'm hoping the other 3 get up so I can avoid Smith

SPP, Barrett and Parfitt/DPP at M11

Pickett and Eddy up front

Passing on Butler, Mountford etc etc

Are Pickett and Eddy on field for you?

[_wato]

Someone quickly tell me why Smith is a good pick. I have one defender spot remaining so gonna choose one out of Otten smith and Hibberd. Go

[GoLions]

Pickett and Eddy up front

Passing on Butler, Mountford etc etc

I'm still trying to decide between Pickett and Butler. Or could just go up to Simpkin or Florent, but they'd be stuck on my bench, so iunno. If Parfitt doesn't get named tonight, then that'll make things easier haha

[GoLions]

Someone quickly tell me why Smith is a good pick. I have one defender spot remaining so gonna choose one out of Otten smith and Hibberd. Go

Hibberd easily imo

[TomK]

Someone quickly tell me why Smith is a good pick. I have one defender spot remaining so gonna choose one out of Otten smith and Hibberd. Go

Hibberd easily imo

[_wato]

Also, what are the chances that Parfitt gets a run? Won't have time to wait for teams.

Might just go Butler to save the hassle. I'd hate to find out Parfitt misses.

[Money Shot]

Also, what are the chances that Parfitt gets a run? Won't have time to wait for teams.

Might just go Butler to save the hassle. I'd hate to find out Parfitt misses.

He should definitely be named imo.

But he could get dropped as he plays sunday

[Woppa15]

Did Wigg need upgrading or already on senior list?

[TomK]

Did Wigg need upgrading or already on senior list?

Already on the senior list but won't be named, look for him as a downgrade option throughout the year though.

[Woppa15]

Did Wigg need upgrading or already on senior list?

Already on the senior list but won't be named, look for him as a downgrade option throughout the year though.

Cheers Tom!

[Purple 77]

JOEL SMITH!

Do we pick him?

Truthfully? His JS has me scared, and I think there are better options out there.

I do think he will score though. Playing sorta that 3rd tall that rebounds. He did have 12 touches in a half, and like 56 DT points in one half in JLT1 (1 more touch for rest of the game though).

But yeah, Hibberd & co are better options IMO