AXV 2017 Rule Discussion

[Ricochet]

Could just change the rule, from being skipped to receiving the next player in AFL order.
   That way in the rare occurrence that a Coach misses they will still get a top draft pick, especially if it's only a rule for the first round of picks.

Yup, I'd be in favour of this, with of course the chance to change your pick before the next person picks

Yeh that's probably a fair compromise




Remember boys this proposal is a very minor adjustment to our rules and would rarely happen. The affect on the comp is literally minimal

But in the unlikely event that something extraordinary happens to a coaches life outside of FF, we have something there

It can't hurt to have it can it

[Rids]

Could just change the rule, from being skipped to receiving the next player in AFL order.
   That way in the rare occurrence that a Coach misses they will still get a top draft pick, especially if it's only a rule for the first round of picks.

Yup, I'd be in favour of this, with of course the chance to change your pick before the next person picks

Yeh that's probably a fair compromise




Remember boys this proposal is a very minor adjustment to our rules and would rarely happen. The affect on the comp is literally minimal

But in the unlikely event that something extraordinary happens to a coaches life outside of FF, we have something there

It can't hurt to have it can it

The discussion is a good one to have and I am sure we can capture a few scenarios to vote on within it.

I understand both sides. Yes life should always be a priority. But delaying also can be a frustration trigger for others with hectic periods coming up. If everyone just give thought to each other then happy days!

[Ricochet]

Could just change the rule, from being skipped to receiving the next player in AFL order.
   That way in the rare occurrence that a Coach misses they will still get a top draft pick, especially if it's only a rule for the first round of picks.

Yup, I'd be in favour of this, with of course the chance to change your pick before the next person picks

Yeh that's probably a fair compromise




Remember boys this proposal is a very minor adjustment to our rules and would rarely happen. The affect on the comp is literally minimal

But in the unlikely event that something extraordinary happens to a coaches life outside of FF, we have something there

It can't hurt to have it can it

The discussion is a good one to have and I am sure we can capture a few scenarios to vote on within it.

I understand both sides. Yes life should always be a priority. But delaying also can be a frustration trigger for others with hectic periods coming up. If everyone just give thought to each other then happy days!

Yep that's the key :)

[upthemaidens]

Has this rule been introduced yet?  If a player quits/delisted and returns to the AFL at a later date, that the previous AXV Club gets to match any bids for that player.
    If not, we should consider adding it.  Basically the same process as WXV.   It only occurs now and then, but still is a good rule to have.

[upthemaidens]

While I'm at it :)    Remove the Rookie list and just make it a 46 man squad.  If we still have a rookie draft, then those players just go onto the seniors.

AFL might get rid of Rookie lists anyhow, but even if they don't we still should.

[nas]

While I'm at it :)    Remove the Rookie list and just make it a 46 man squad.  If we still have a rookie draft, then those players just go onto the seniors.

AFL might get rid of Rookie lists anyhow, but even if they don't we still should.

Looked at mid November & maybe implementing next season.

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,66981.5000.html

[Ricochet]

Has this rule been introduced yet?  If a player quits/delisted and returns to the AFL at a later date, that the previous AXV Club gets to match any bids for that player.
    If not, we should consider adding it.  Basically the same process as WXV.   It only occurs now and then, but still is a good rule to have.

Yeh i like this one too

[Rids]

While I'm at it :)    Remove the Rookie list and just make it a 46 man squad.  If we still have a rookie draft, then those players just go onto the seniors.

AFL might get rid of Rookie lists anyhow, but even if they don't we still should.

We will need to put this to a vote for the 2018 AXV season as teams would have traded and drafted accordingly. Rookie list will need to remain for the 2017 season.