Which trade to do for my team? No idea what to do with Deledio and Hall.

[Judd Magic]

Have no idea if I should trade Deledio and Hall.

Knowing my luck I will trade them out and they will be back next week. LOL!

Do I just trade Menadue > Franklin and hope that Lids and Hall are back next week or week after?

2 trades left and $150,000


B - Shaw, Laird, Simpson, Rance, McVeigh, Collins (Boyd, Lee)
C - Dangerfield, Hannerbery, Ward, Parker, Pendles, Neale, Rockliff, Gray (Mathieson,Trengove, Phillips)
R - Goldstein, Gawn (Goetz)
F - D.Martin, Montagna, Merrett, Deledio, Kerridge, Hipwood (Hall, Menadue)

[RaisyDaisy]

Menadue to Buddy and hold the other trade

[tkringle]

Yeah it's the not knowing with Lids that is frustrating.. Thinking of trading him to Gunston

[Judd Magic]

Menadue to Buddy and hold the other trade

Kinda thinking Menadue > Buddy might be a good idea RD because if Lids and Hall come back I will have a full premo forward line -

Martin, Merrett, Deledio, Franklin, Montagna, Hall (Kerridge, Hipwood)

That forward line looks pretty good on paper.

[Judd Magic]

Yeah it's the not knowing with Lids that is frustrating.. Thinking of trading him to Gunston

Yeah its frustrating mate because I read this week that Deledio was training on his own which shows that he isn't a write off yet but just didn't get up for this week.

So there is still hope that he could play next week or week after.

I would spew if I traded Deledio out this week only for him to return next week. Hah!

[_wato]

Dimma did say Lids will play again before the year is out so can't be far away

[Judd Magic]

Dimma did say Lids will play again before the year is out so can't be far away

Yeah that's why I am reluctant to trade him out for mate.

That along with what I said above about Lids training this week but away from the main group which means he isn't a write off yet and maybe isn't too far away?  :-\

[_wato]

Dimma did say Lids will play again before the year is out so can't be far away

Yeah that's why I am reluctant to trade him out for mate.

That along with what I said above about Lids training this week but away from the main group which means he isn't a write off yet and maybe isn't too far away?  :-\

Yeah I hate that man, because you really don't have any idea at all.

If I was you, I'd do the trade and bring in Buddy, nets you 95 points straight up and if Lids misses any more his value becomes even more important.

The only way I see you losing on that trade is if Buddy gets rested but I doubt it. Im one of those who will not cop a donut at this time of year and if it means burning a trade then go for it

[Judd Magic]

Dimma did say Lids will play again before the year is out so can't be far away

Yeah that's why I am reluctant to trade him out for mate.

That along with what I said above about Lids training this week but away from the main group which means he isn't a write off yet and maybe isn't too far away?  :-\

Yeah I hate that man, because you really don't have any idea at all.

If I was you, I'd do the trade and bring in Buddy, nets you 95 points straight up and if Lids misses any more his value becomes even more important.

The only way I see you losing on that trade is if Buddy gets rested but I doubt it. Im one of those who will not cop a donut at this time of year and if it means burning a trade then go for it

I hate copping donuts too.

Copped one last week as I wanted to know more about Lids and Halls injuries and I think I was a few grand short of going Menadue > Buddy anyways. Now Buddy has dropped in price again I can just afford Menadue > Buddy. LOL!

Only thing that sucks is that I am playing my forward bench cover on the ground in Kerridge and Hipwood.

Better than a donut though I suppose.  :-\

[King_Robbo]

Menaspud to Buddy the obvious choice.
A roughie could be Toby Greene. Could go nuts v Richmond this week

[crowls]

Thinking  keep Hall and Lids.   Trade Adams via Joyce and Phillips to a Mid/Fwd or Fwd
Options are Touk Miller,  3gm=101, 5gm=87
Toby Greene 3gm=91, 5gm=92
Buddy 3gm=85, 5gm=95
Clay Smith 3gm=87, 5gm=88


Got 443k to spend. 
Touk would be big POD option.   Certainly going to be around the ball a lot for GCS.


Need the forward coverage or would have considered, Aaron Francis for Adams.  Whitecross is a cheap option for Philips and dpp link with adams.  But go into finals with Adams, Hall and Lids all still injured.
3 trades left atm.   2 after this week if I trade Adams.
Thoughts?

[crowls]

Thinking  keep Hall and Lids.   Trade Adams via Joyce and Phillips to a Mid/Fwd or Fwd
Options are Touk Miller,  3gm=101, 5gm=87
Toby Greene 3gm=91, 5gm=92
Buddy 3gm=85, 5gm=95
Clay Smith 3gm=87, 5gm=88


Got 443k to spend. 
Touk would be big POD option.   Certainly going to be around the ball a lot for GCS.


Need the forward coverage or would have considered, Aaron Francis for Adams.  Whitecross is a cheap option for Philips and dpp link with adams.  But go into finals with Adams, Hall and Lids all still injured.
3 trades left atm.   2 after this week if I trade Adams.
Thoughts?

Now considering Lycett as Fwd cover.   Keep lids, hall, trade adams via dpp.   Will end up with Lycett/Hall/Lids and Naismith as F7/8  and Collins/Joyce as D7/8.  M9/10/11  Petracca/Matho/Phillips.   13k in bank and 2 trades for finals?   Poor bench cover for backs and lose dpp swing but cover donut in Rucks/fwds this week.