WXV Official Trade Confabulation

Started by meow meow, July 13, 2016, 09:21:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ricochet

Holz show us a before and after Dublin squad for this trade period

Levi434

Who has a 30-50 rookie pick for trade?

Holz

Quote from: Ricochet on November 18, 2016, 11:32:29 AM
Holz show us a before and after Dublin squad for this trade period

I update my original page so just going off the top of my head.

Rance Birchall Weits Grundy - Omac Yarran Jetta Byrne William Frost Hansen
Selwood Treloar Sloane Murphy - Jetta
Goldy - Daw
Gunston Jroo Buddy Dmart - Kennedy Schoey Silvagni Crocker Dale
NDS Collins

to

Rance Tmac Birchall Yarran - Weits Omac Collins Vickers-Willis Durdin Nielson
Dmart Treloar Sloane Jones - Jack Trengove
Goldy - Preuss
Gunston Jroo Hoff Daw - Turner Schoey Silvagni Greenwood Menzel
Crouch Hill

so basically upgrade down back i reckon matched by a downgrade up forward. The ruck is the same but now i have all north rucks in Goldy Daw Preuss Durdin so slight improve.

But the midfield despite the loss of selwood is a slight increase with Dmart = Selwood and then Jones a upgrade on Murphy (hge upgrade considering he missed most of the year)

The big difference is that Utility Bench. The change is phenomenal NDS + Collins but givne murphy was injured it was basically Weits Collins and now its upgrade to Brad Crouch + Stephen Hill which is big enough but now Kieran Jack on the bench.

Very very happy with trade period this year.

However i gave up alot of talent with all my picks gone and then kennedy who was a top 5 pick. 

iZander

Dillos still open for trade!

Ed Curnow, Isaac Smith, Travis Boak all up for trade, hoping to downgrade them in age with a picks/sweeteners.

Defender wise, guys like Marcus Adams and Zach Tuohy could be traded also :P

Ricochet

Quote from: Holz on November 18, 2016, 11:45:02 AM
Quote from: Ricochet on November 18, 2016, 11:32:29 AM
Holz show us a before and after Dublin squad for this trade period

I update my original page so just going off the top of my head.

Rance Birchall Weits Grundy - Omac Yarran Jetta Byrne William Frost Hansen
Selwood Treloar Sloane Murphy - Jetta
Goldy - Daw
Gunston Jroo Buddy Dmart - Kennedy Schoey Silvagni Crocker Dale
NDS Collins

to

Rance Tmac Birchall Yarran - Weits Omac Collins Vickers-Willis Durdin Nielson
Dmart Treloar Sloane Jones - Jack Trengove
Goldy - Preuss
Gunston Jroo Hoff Daw - Turner Schoey Silvagni Greenwood Menzel
Crouch Hill

so basically upgrade down back i reckon matched by a downgrade up forward. The ruck is the same but now i have all north rucks in Goldy Daw Preuss Durdin so slight improve.

But the midfield despite the loss of selwood is a slight increase with Dmart = Selwood and then Jones a upgrade on Murphy (hge upgrade considering he missed most of the year)

The big difference is that Utility Bench. The change is phenomenal NDS + Collins but givne murphy was injured it was basically Weits Collins and now its upgrade to Brad Crouch + Stephen Hill which is big enough but now Kieran Jack on the bench.

Very very happy with trade period this year.

However i gave up alot of talent with all my picks gone and then kennedy who was a top 5 pick.
Right ok, but if it was the start of next year and Yarran and Roughead were healthy you'd include them

So changes are
Weits vs TMac
Murphy vs NJones
Jelwood vs Crouch
Franklin vs Hoff
Roughead vs Daw
Jetta vs SHill
annnd got KJack as depth

But that's if Yarran and Roughie are healthy next year

So many changes to a starting XV of an already super strong XV :o

Holz

Quote from: Ricochet on November 18, 2016, 12:04:46 PM
Quote from: Holz on November 18, 2016, 11:45:02 AM
Quote from: Ricochet on November 18, 2016, 11:32:29 AM
Holz show us a before and after Dublin squad for this trade period

I update my original page so just going off the top of my head.

Rance Birchall Weits Grundy - Omac Yarran Jetta Byrne William Frost Hansen
Selwood Treloar Sloane Murphy - Jetta
Goldy - Daw
Gunston Jroo Buddy Dmart - Kennedy Schoey Silvagni Crocker Dale
NDS Collins

to

Rance Tmac Birchall Yarran - Weits Omac Collins Vickers-Willis Durdin Nielson
Dmart Treloar Sloane Jones - Jack Trengove
Goldy - Preuss
Gunston Jroo Hoff Daw - Turner Schoey Silvagni Greenwood Menzel
Crouch Hill

so basically upgrade down back i reckon matched by a downgrade up forward. The ruck is the same but now i have all north rucks in Goldy Daw Preuss Durdin so slight improve.

But the midfield despite the loss of selwood is a slight increase with Dmart = Selwood and then Jones a upgrade on Murphy (hge upgrade considering he missed most of the year)

The big difference is that Utility Bench. The change is phenomenal NDS + Collins but givne murphy was injured it was basically Weits Collins and now its upgrade to Brad Crouch + Stephen Hill which is big enough but now Kieran Jack on the bench.

Very very happy with trade period this year.

However i gave up alot of talent with all my picks gone and then kennedy who was a top 5 pick.
Right ok, but if it was the start of next year and Yarran and Roughead were healthy you'd include them

So changes are
Weits vs TMac
Murphy vs NJones
Jelwood vs Crouch
Franklin vs Hoff
Roughead vs Daw
Jetta vs SHill
annnd got KJack as depth

But that's if Yarran and Roughie are healthy next year

So many changes to a starting XV of an already super strong XV :o

The other thins is the team got younger aswell.

thats part of it, like Selwood to Tmac Hill is about strengthening lines but i also traded 28 year old guy for a 24 and 25. 

Levi434

Looking to trade 1 of Zaharakis, Mitch Robinson or Danyle Pearce for a forward. 75ave or over.

GoLions

I liked the old Dublin better. I heard they had blackjack every Tuesday and Thursday. Now they just have Kieran Jack. Smh.

Also, let's get to 100+ trades boyzzz.

Purple 77


RaisyDaisy


Purple 77

Aaron Vandenberg or Hayden Ballantyne is tradeable, given my Menzel acquisition

Ricochet

Quote from: Purple 77 on November 18, 2016, 02:06:29 PM
Aaron Vandenberg or Hayden Ballantyne is tradeable, given my Menzel acquisition
I swear i saw him traded to Dublin?

meow meow


RaisyDaisy

LOL Yep I saw that too

Must have changed their minds


RaisyDaisy

So we have to have our lists lodged by Nov 30

What dates are we doing the NAT, PSD and Rookie drafts? I know I read it somewhere before but can't find it