WXV Official Trade Confabulation

[Holz]

I blame Holz.

Do something evil so we can argue for weeks.

Its brewing

[RaisyDaisy]

How many more votes are we waiting on?

Kind of annoying that every deal that doesn't involve spuds always seems to get negs from some coaches

The 3 trades in question are all easily fair. Nobody is getting bent over

[Purple 77]

Votes are in!

Trade 1
Dublin trade: Samuel Collins
New York trade: Kayne Turner + Pick 51
Votes: 0
Admin comments: Meh.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 2
Dublin trade: Daniel Currie + Pick 54
Buenos Aires trade: Kieran Collins + Pick 49
Votes: 0
Admin comments: Meh.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 3
Christchurch trade: Pick 9 + Pick 28
Seoul trade: Thomas Boyd
Votes: 1
Admin comments: Fair enough.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 4
Dublin trade: Marc Murphy + Pick 72
New Delhi trade: Kieren Jack + Pick 55
Votes: 0
Admin comments: 3 Dublin trades, 0 negs, great to see!
Verdict: PASS

Trade 5
Cairo trade: Shaun Higgins
Christchurch trade: Koby Stevens, Pick 46, Pick 64 + Pick 82
Votes: 1
Admin comments: Yup, all good. Higgins the biggest fantasy tease I know.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 6 (unconfirmed)
Rio de Janeiro trade: Robert Murphy
Christchurch trade: Matthew Boyd
Votes: 1
Admin comments: Oldie for Oldie, defender for defender.
Verdict: PASS, but not official until Rio confirmation.

Trade 7
Cairo trade: Kamdyn McIntosh + Charlie Curnow
Seoul trade: Jack Newnes + Jason Castagna
Votes: 0
Admin comments: Good trade.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 8
New Delhi trade: Tom $cully + Pick 18
New York trade: Bachar Houli, Harley Balic + Brayden Fiorini
Votes: 4
Admin comments: Hmm. A few coaches made mention of this trade and in some eyes felt the late pick upgrade stopped it from being neg worthy. Houli last year matched $cully this year in scoring.... but I suppose $cully is on the up and is younger... for arguments sake, I'll take NY's word for it and say $cully is a little > than Houli. Balic & Fiorini were WXV picks 19 & 20 last year, so I'll be generous and say Pick 18 = Fiorini. Does Balic = that difference between Houli & $cully? I'd say Balic > difference. I have a feeling this trade was agreed upon weeks ago, before Fiorini had those great two games, which sparked the late pick upgrade. But this is an example of why you don't agree to a trade before the trade period opens :P. I personally don't like the trade, but enough to overturn the PASS decision to a REJECTION? Probably not. As much as it pains me, I can see how that $cully valuation came to be, so I'll give the coaches the benefit of the doubt.
Verdict: PASS

Trade 9
New York trade: Nakia Cockatoo, Nathan Hrovat + Pick 33
Cape Town trade: Dom Tyson + Pick 44
Votes: 3
Admin comments: Aw, Tyson 103 average from last 6 weeks and starting to step into elite category IRL in second half of year... lucky it didn't get to 4 votes IMO, as I'm not a fan.  Pressure on Cockatoo to perform!
Verdict: PASS

Trade 10
PNL trade: Zachary Williams, Billy Stretch, Pick 15 + Pick 70
Tokyo trade: Paddy Ryder, Pick 4 + Pick 41
Votes: 3
Admin comments: Valuable components in this trade. I actually quite like it despite some coaches feeling Tokyo is overpaying. 
Verdict: PASS

Trade 11
Christchurch trade: Shaun McKernan
Rio de Janeiro trade: Pick 56
Votes: 0
Admin comments: Hehe.
Verdict: PASS

[Torpedo10]

Ok.

So Robbie Gray MIGHT be for sale.

Offers via PM please.

[Hellopplz]

Weren't you offering him up a few weeks ago? :P. He's as good as gone this period I reckon as he seems disgruntled on Moscow's plans for his future.

[GoLions]

Weren't you offering him up a few weeks ago? :P. He's as good as gone this period I reckon as he seems disgruntled on Moscow's plans for his future.

He was :P

[RaisyDaisy]

Torp has been shopping around most of their guns already, but does he have the stones to actually agree to a deal and trade?  :P

Ima say probably not, because he wants too much :P

[Torpedo10]

Torp has been shopping around most of their guns already, but does he have the stones to actually agree to a deal and trade?  :P

Ima say probably not, because he wants too much :P

Is that like when you guys rejected the first Ward deal because I wanted too much there?

Please.  :P

[Hellopplz]

Justin Westhoff is looking towards a move to help his Premiership chances before his career is out. PNL are shocked at the announcement of his lack of faith in the club, especially his close friend Matthew Lobbe.

We went to Matthew for a comment, but he needed 5 minutes to compose himself.

[fanTCfool]

Love the reference

[RaisyDaisy]

Alright, we're looking pretty solid and bat deep now in both the mids and def, so we're looking for a starting forward and have the picks and players to pay up for one

If you've got a starting forward, hit me up

[Purple 77]

We went to Matthew for a comment, but he needed 5 minutes to compose himself.

This makes me happy.

[Nige]

We went to Matthew for a comment, but he needed 5 minutes to compose himself.

This makes me happy.

I genuinely laughed out loud hahaha.

[upthemaidens]

Just a heads-up, the last trade between Berlin and Dublin has #72 included, Dublin used that pick already in an earlier trade..

[ossie85]

Just a heads-up, the last trade between Berlin and Dublin has #72 included, Dublin used that pick already in an earlier trade..

I'll tell that to him now... he's about to get in a car with me