Silvagni - Jump on early or not?

[Raiden]

Anyone going early on Silvagni? I'm considering off loading Petracca for him this week.

Not many forward downgrade options atm apart from Hipwood (named) or Reid (not named)

[RaisyDaisy]

If you need him to avoid a donut or get cash to complete another trade I reckon it's OK at this time of the year if he will be your F8

13k+ people have already traded him in

[Raiden]

Yeah it's a pure cash grab that will allow two trades, 1 upgrade & 1 luxury - It will mean that i will have him & Menadue on the bench with Phillips MID/FWD swing (That's not getting games)

[LF]

I got him in last week lucky I did otherwise I'd be stuffed this week

[no eye deer]

I wanted to cash in Kerredge for a 103k DPP non playing rookie to loophole, but with all the other rookies not playing I'm going to have to spend the extra on Silvagni now.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :o

Just traded him in.

[GoLions]

Got him last week

[fanTCfool]

I'm on, JS is solid and there isn't a heap on the horizon.

[Blues Blues Blues]

I'm on, JS is solid and there isn't a heap on the horizon.

Is it solid though? Only a young kid. I hope so as I want to trade him this week but worried he'll get dropped at some stage

[Mark]

JS really that good ?

I think he will play 3-4 games max.

Hope I'm incorrect

[RaisyDaisy]

JS is not solid, but it's better than any other rookie coming through

[fanTCfool]

A Silvagni playing at Carlton, the JS is never going to be too bad.

[Jesty]

The kid did pretty well I thought with the pressure that was on him, crowd factor etc. I reckon they will play him every week. The season will be over soon enough.
In for me.

[Mark]

I'm sticking to my prediction..

Let him be named in his 3rd before I trade him in

[Goosey]

I brought him in last week to save a donut, F7 E this week.