Round 16 Trades

[WhatMate]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

[JBodhi]

I'm now leaning towards trading Zaha... Struggling with who to though. I'm tossing up between Trealor, Parker, Hunter, Lewis and Steven. My current midfield prems are Danger, Rocky, Titch, Pendles, Ablett, Hanners. Any thoughts would be much appreciated.

[jvalles69]

I'm now leaning towards trading Zaha... Struggling with who to though. I'm tossing up between Trealor, Parker, Hunter, Lewis and Steven. My current midfield prems are Danger, Rocky, Titch, Pendles, Ablett, Hanners. Any thoughts would be much appreciated.

I'd go Steven.

Decided my trade...I'm going full Zorko!  8)

[Chelskiman]

Zaha > Rocky
Collins > Kelly

[Jalapeno]

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

[jvalles69]

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

[Jukes]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

Actually, now that I've looked into it I'd go with Clay over Silvagni. I'd stick with Gaffy tho - he's cheaper and Mitch will probably get the Kane Mitch tag this week (this coming from a guy with Mitch and not Gaff)

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

If the saints tag any of our guys (which really they shouldn't have to because they'll kill us anyway) I'd lean towards it being Zacka, seeing as how much it can affect him. I agree with the price thing though, I'd calculate it but lazy aha

[jvalles69]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

Actually, now that I've looked into it I'd go with Clay over Silvagni. I'd stick with Gaffy tho - he's cheaper and Mitch will probably get the Kane Mitch tag this week (this coming from a guy with Mitch and not Gaff)

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

If the saints tag any of our guys (which really they shouldn't have to because they'll kill us anyway) I'd lean towards it being Zacka, seeing as how much it can affect him. I agree with the price thing though, I'd calculate it but lazy aha

Zaha is suspended, so Zerrett will get tagged if any.

[Jukes]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

Actually, now that I've looked into it I'd go with Clay over Silvagni. I'd stick with Gaffy tho - he's cheaper and Mitch will probably get the Kane Mitch tag this week (this coming from a guy with Mitch and not Gaff)

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

If the saints tag any of our guys (which really they shouldn't have to because they'll kill us anyway) I'd lean towards it being Zacka, seeing as how much it can affect him. I agree with the price thing though, I'd calculate it but lazy aha

Zaha is suspended, so Zerrett will get tagged if any.

Right, I still have a feeling he won't cop a hard tag tho...should still score 100 or there abouts

[jvalles69]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

Actually, now that I've looked into it I'd go with Clay over Silvagni. I'd stick with Gaffy tho - he's cheaper and Mitch will probably get the Kane Mitch tag this week (this coming from a guy with Mitch and not Gaff)

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

If the saints tag any of our guys (which really they shouldn't have to because they'll kill us anyway) I'd lean towards it being Zacka, seeing as how much it can affect him. I agree with the price thing though, I'd calculate it but lazy aha

Zaha is suspended, so Zerrett will get tagged if any.

Right, I still have a feeling he won't cop a hard tag tho...should still score 100 or there abouts

Hope so, I brought Zerret in last week!

[Jukes]

Gaff vs S.Mitchell
Silvagni vs Clay Smith

My dilemma for the week

Gaff and Silvagni imo

Hmm well that's interesting. I was slightly leaning towards Smith for JS and Smitchell for having a higher scoring output come seasons end

Actually, now that I've looked into it I'd go with Clay over Silvagni. I'd stick with Gaffy tho - he's cheaper and Mitch will probably get the Kane Mitch tag this week (this coming from a guy with Mitch and not Gaff)

Need a hand deciding on my final trade for the week please guys....

Option 1: C Dempsey > R Laird

Option 2: S Kerridge > Z Merrett

Thanks guys :)

Thats tough, Zerrett is the bigger scorer, but will he get tagged this week by Ross?  Long run you want both, so I guess go with BE's and bring in the guy who will go up in price next week.

If the saints tag any of our guys (which really they shouldn't have to because they'll kill us anyway) I'd lean towards it being Zacka, seeing as how much it can affect him. I agree with the price thing though, I'd calculate it but lazy aha

Zaha is suspended, so Zerrett will get tagged if any.

Right, I still have a feeling he won't cop a hard tag tho...should still score 100 or there abouts

Hope so, I brought Zerret in last week!

And I'm trading him in this week aha, hopefully choosing him over Joey and Roo doesn't hurt me!

[Jalapeno]

Thanks guys :)

I think I will go with the first option as I feel Kerridge will outscore Dempsey this week.

Then Next week ill upgrade Kerridge to Zerrett :)

[Dave085]

I'm tossing up whether to double downgrade. Going for league rather than overall. Currently sitting top with a game in hand. Can afford to drop a game but reckon I can still get over the line with trade 1.


Trade 1
Kerridge to Silvagni, Blakely to Clay Smith. Means I have $612k in the bank. 1 rookie on field in each line (Collins in def, one of C. Smith/Mathieson in mids and Silvagni/Hams in Fwd).
Next week I can upgrade Hams to Merrett. I plan to upgrade downgrade for the rest of the year and have enough money to swap premos based on matchups.

Trade 2
Kerridge to Silvagni, Harwood to Kelly, leaves $216 in the bank.

I'm just worried about cash cows from after this round with JS and feel Clay Smith will be too expensive next week.
Kerridge is not in my plans for the year and don't feel he will score well this week so may drop more in price. Hams BE is still low.

[Dave085]

Any quick opinion on the above trades?

[DBRiMatt]

Too late to be relevant, but I would have liked Trade 2.
As nice as double downgrades are, I think after the byes you really want to look at a downgrade/upgrade.