My last Backline upgrade.. Plz help

[Mark]

Who would be the best upgrade for Petracca via Brown DDP...

I'm thinking Pittard - Williams or even Gibson ??

Current backline in Laird - Rance - Shaw - Docherty - Simpson

Thanks in advance

[RaisyDaisy]

All 3 are good options

Pittard - Gibson - Williams would be my order, but all good options

[Raiden]

Gibson > Pittard/Williams is my order (Tough call between Williams & Pittard thou, pretty much even)

[ronl]

The entire Geelong team put in a shocker vs the Saints on the weekend, but over a 12 game stretch prior to that Bartel averaged close to 105ppg.  Now that they've got that stinker out of the way Geelong should hit back hard and Jimmyl should revert back to his previous excellent form. Of the three players you mentioned I really like Williams, a star in the making, and his 141 is a sure sign of things to come.

[King_Robbo]

The entire Geelong team put in a shocker vs the Saints on the weekend, but over a 12 game stretch prior to that Bartel averaged close to 105ppg.  Now that they've got that stinker out of the way Geelong should hit back hard and Jimmyl should revert back to his previous excellent form. Of the three players you mentioned I really like Williams, a star in the making, and his 141 is a sure sign of things to come.

Really good call, I think Bartel will do very well in the run home, especially with his draw and the amount of games at silled stadium (4 from memory). However, I think Williams represents better value in terms of money and has a very comfortable run home too.

I wouldnt go near Gibson or Pittard. I dont like the way Pittard plays (gets a lot of outside ball) and Gibson is way too up and down (50 one week 100 the next). I think Gibbo will average 85-95 fom here.~

Bartel would be my pick if you purely want the points. Williams if you want to save a little coin and go unique

[Mark]

Bartel added to poll when it was 4 Pittard 4 Willian's 2 gibbo

[GoLions]

Are you doing the upgrade this week? If so, then gotta go Pittard imo as he's had his bye already.

Also consider Zorko ;)

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 :)

Out of those you chose    Bartel.  But Cats have a very, very soft last 4 games. Would Sctt rest bench or General Soreness some of his aging stars in that time ??  Plus Cats have the bye this week, to be totally honest have you considered McVeigh ??  Only 1 trade for me this week and that's McVeigh in for Weitering. Best of luck and cheers.      ;)

[Mark]

Are you doing the upgrade this week? If so, then gotta go Pittard imo as he's had his bye already.

Also consider Zorko ;)

Yeah upgrade this week...

And if Zorko was a Backman I'd get him just for u GoLions  ;)

[Mark]

If JJ is back this week would he have to be considered ??

[Huttabito]

If JJ is back this week would he have to be considered ??

I'd have to look away everytime he got the ball.

Too risky for me with such limited trades left to be picking up a bloke who's had 11 weeks off with a hamstring.

[TurtlesTeam]

JJ is in for me, can't resist the juicy upgrade option for Ruggles.

[Mark]

Bartel easy winning, then Williams is a surprise over Pittard..

Do people think Williams is a better and SAFER pick then Pittard ?

[djbics]

Are you doing the upgrade this week? If so, then gotta go Pittard imo as he's had his bye already.

Also consider Zorko ;)

Yeah upgrade this week...

And if Zorko was a Backman I'd get him just for u GoLions  ;)

Maybe I'm missing something but surely Pittard is the only option worth doing this week???  As the other guys have the bye and aren't playing, and Petracca still has money to make, this trade doesn't need to be done until next week at the earliest.

[Mark]

Nah mate you aren't missing anything.

Just wanted to see if Pittsrd was the favourite out of all and if he was he was entering this week.

But not trading as either get Bartel or Williams next week