Round 15 trades...

Started by Mark, June 26, 2016, 05:20:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ringo

With Barlow out for 3/4 Barlow to Montagna


Hazza09

If you had to trade Hopper/Hall/Kerridge/Barlow/Adams...who out of the 3 would go?

I wanted to upgrade Adams - Docherty as my final defence upgrade.
Do you keep Barlow for the 3-4 weeks or trade him to Lids or N Roo?

That means one of Hooper/Hall or Kerridge stays...... Hooper can be a M11 donut/loophole but not sure who to hold between Hall and Kerridge.

Carnage!

TurtlesTeam

Just watched Bulldogs team news and JJ is back. He is my 15th round in for sure. Sorry ruggles but your services are no longer required

Fid

Lee  into Nankervis  via Adams (ruck cover)

Milera into Deledio

Weitering into Broad

tttt

why is everyone jumping on the trade barlow option?
article says barlow is out for 3-4, so after his bye thats 2-3, isnt that worth a hold?

Fid

#50
Quote from: tttt on June 28, 2016, 09:07:44 PM
why is everyone jumping on the trade barlow option?
article says barlow is out for 3-4, so after his bye thats 2-3, isnt that worth a hold?

If coaches are holding Dahlhaus and Wells as well as Barlow, it's a flowering huge concern...

I thankfully only have Wells (off loaded Barlow and  Dahlhaus a few weeks back)  :'(


TurtlesTeam

Barlow out!!!  Seriously, this is so messed up.

tttt

Quote from: Fid on June 28, 2016, 09:12:36 PM
Quote from: tttt on June 28, 2016, 09:07:44 PM
why is everyone jumping on the trade barlow option?
article says barlow is out for 3-4, so after his bye thats 2-3, isnt that worth a hold?

If coaches are holding Dahlhaus and Wells as well as Barlow, it's a flowering huge concern...

I thankfully only have Wells (off loaded Barlow and  Dahlhaus a few weeks back)  :'(

yea would be a concern if they had dahl. Ive got both wells and barlow but i genuinely believe wells will play after his bye  :P
and i have kerridge sitting on the bench for now, so will just put him on field and hold barlow for as long as i can :P

Ringo

Quote from: tttt on June 28, 2016, 09:46:08 PM
Quote from: Fid on June 28, 2016, 09:12:36 PM
Quote from: tttt on June 28, 2016, 09:07:44 PM
why is everyone jumping on the trade barlow option?
article says barlow is out for 3-4, so after his bye thats 2-3, isnt that worth a hold?

If coaches are holding Dahlhaus and Wells as well as Barlow, it's a flowering huge concern...

I thankfully only have Wells (off loaded Barlow and  Dahlhaus a few weeks back)  :'(

yea would be a concern if they had dahl. Ive got both wells and barlow but i genuinely believe wells will play after his bye  :P
and i have kerridge sitting on the bench for now, so will just put him on field and hold barlow for as long as i can :P
If you are fighting to get into Top 4 in Leagues at this stage of the season can not afford to have Barlow on the pine for even 2 weeks after byes.  Remember Finals are only 5 weeks away including this week so positioning team for Top 4 in Leagues is a consideration.  Trading Barlow to Zerrett who will score as well if not better than Barlow is a good move this week with goal in mind and now gives me 19 on field.

sammy123


ivolve

I'd hold Barlow, but then again I traded him in round 2and kicked myself.

Do I go Kerridge to Merrett this week or hold off for 2 and go to Zorko?

Going for league win, playing the longame with 10 trades left.

Cheers

King_Robbo

Quote from: TurtlesTeam on June 28, 2016, 09:14:34 PM
Barlow out!!!  Seriously, this is so messed up.

God I'm so glad I jumped off this roller coaster in Rd 2.

Gigantor

Brand > Pittard
Davis > Hanners
Barlow > Treloar (had Montagna in my Midfield)

Plan is next week
Lee > Uebergang (Adams currently F7)
Kerridge > Neale

Really wanted Sloane but would have to trade out Collins instead which I don't think is worth it.

Will have 4 trades left with decent bench coverage, would love to have a couple more trades left but shower happens  ;D

Asparagus

Quote from: ivolve on June 29, 2016, 01:10:51 AM
I'd hold Barlow, but then again I traded him in round 2and kicked myself.

Do I go Kerridge to Merrett this week or hold off for 2 and go to Zorko?

Going for league win, playing the longame with 10 trades left.

Cheers
I am going for league win as well and also have 10 trades left.
Had Barlow form the start and he has been good overall and I will be holding him.

If I were you I would hold off trading Kerridge and aim for Zorko in 2 weeks. That way if an unforeseen injury pops up you can deal with it.
Plus I would prefer Zork over Merrett anyway.

AaronKirk

Quote from: tttt on June 28, 2016, 09:07:44 PM
why is everyone jumping on the trade barlow option?
article says barlow is out for 3-4, so after his bye thats 2-3, isnt that worth a hold?

If you have a decent amount of trades left the extra score this week means you are better off trading him.

We also do not know if he has to play WAFL before he comes back or how Ross will use him when he returns.

The safer option is to trade him. Montagna comes into my side for him this week.

My other trade at this stage is Brand to Broad. I want to trade Mumford to Jacobs but that cuts it fine on trades after this week.