Poll: Laird or Rance?

[PowerBug]

it's raining cats and dogs in Adelaide right now and is going to be a shocking night. Disposal efficiency will be well down I reckon. I'm not confident more than two blokes will go over 100 tonight.

Therefore Rance this week!

3300 points are handed out per game. If everyone goes at 40% and Laird goes at 60% I have a fair idea as to who will get the good chunk of the points ;)

I don't think you can go wrong with either, but I started with Rance and traded Laird in when he returned from injury, so I guess Rance is my preferred pick :)

[js19]

My final 6 has neither in there, but if given a choice I'd pick Laird.

Just feel more confident with a running player that gets some mid time, although Rance does have a great SC ratio due to his spoils and intercepts

[GVSKiwi]

Is docherty worth the extra 100k?

[js19]

Is docherty worth the extra 100k?

Depends where you spend it. I've got Doc, but also have Priddis/Libba in mids. Probably rather a Laird/Hanners combo tbh, but can't have it all

[Huttabito]

Is docherty worth the extra 100k?

I'm either Docherty then McKenzie D7 or a combo along the lines of McVeigh and Yeo D7 for better loopholing/cover.

Can't help but think Dochers is overpriced. Thankfully this is next weeks problem and can assess him one last week.

[kilbluff1985]

picked Laird cause i like his run home better he is my D6

Shaw, Boyd, Bartel, Simmo, Laird, McVeigh

[dylanclements]

picked Laird cause i like his run home better he is my D6

Had to make this decision and went this way too - think it was probably the right call.

Shaw, Boyd, Bartel, Simmo, Laird, McVeigh

Me too  8)

[StuL]

;)

I'm taking Simmo and Rance this week.  Howe the following week and then Bartel the week after.  Left my defence until last when I'd have a better idea.  Other two defenders are Shaw and Docherty.  I'd definitely take Rance first as he has a higher scoring draw in the coming weeks and should score you more points initially.  Cheers.      ;)

I wanted Simo and Rance all along. Should just stick to my guns. Well I am, I didn't take Laird.

[jumbo]

it's raining cats and dogs in Adelaide right now and is going to be a shocking night. Disposal efficiency will be well down I reckon. I'm not confident more than two blokes will go over 100 tonight.

Therefore Rance this week!

3300 points are handed out per game. If everyone goes at 40% and Laird goes at 60% I have a fair idea as to who will get the good chunk of the points ;)

I don't think you can go wrong with either, but I started with Rance and traded Laird in when he returned from injury, so I guess Rance is my preferred pick :)

Thanks for the scoring lesson powerbug.  Weather turned out not as bad as I thought during the game. Laird 91 was good for those that got him in at 80%

[ronl]

Rance has a much higher ceiling imo.