Poll: Laird or Rance?

[StuL]

Laird or Rance? I was set on Rance but 'The Phantom' loves Laird and said 'definitely' him first. But I disagree with a lot of what he said and I'm ranked better than him. I normally don't like talls in defence either but Rance has the track record and this year is proving to be the year of the tall in defence.

[King_Robbo]

I'm getting both this week but if I had to choose one I would go with Rance purely because he has a great draw coming up
Either way I don't think you're going wrong

[StuL]

I'm getting both this week but if I had to choose one I would go with Rance purely because he has a great draw coming up
Either way I don't think you're going wrong

And the Poll is pretty much what I thought it would be too. 50/50

[Big Mac]

I'd grab Rance

[Blues Blues Blues]

Is Bartel worth the extra $50k?

[StuL]

Is Bartel worth the extra $50k?

Yes but have him. Only ones on my shopping list are Simpson, Laird and Rance. Prob get Simo next week

[tkringle]

I'm wrestling with Simmo vs Rance this week..

Leaning towards Simmo purely from a consistency perspective but the $50K if i went Rance would be useful!

[Ringo]

Would go Rance as he is favoured by CD SC Stats. He conisitently scores more in SC than other comps.

[mzunguman]

I'm wrestling with Simmo vs Rance this week..

Leaning towards Simmo purely from a consistency perspective but the $50K if i went Rance would be useful!

[Holz]

I'm wrestling with Simmo vs Rance this week..

Leaning towards Simmo purely from a consistency perspective but the $50K if i went Rance would be useful!

Rance easy.

95 76 98 104 in the last month seems pretty consistent to me.

Simmo has GWS, pies, crows , eagles, sydney, hawks then his draw opens up. If you can use the $50k then go Rance. Looks set for 95-100 average.

[Sabretooth Tigers]

 ;)

I'm taking Simmo and Rance this week.  Howe the following week and then Bartel the week after.  Left my defence until last when I'd have a better idea.  Other two defenders are Shaw and Docherty.  I'd definitely take Rance first as he has a higher scoring draw in the coming weeks and should score you more points initially.  Cheers.      ;)

[Jimmykidd]

crows have a good draw coming up. i have them both but if i had to chose id take laird

[timtim]

Laird for me - even though they're playing brisbane this week I'm not sure how much action Rance will see down back. At least with Laird he's playing that running role across half back and racks up touches

[batt]

I'm going Laird so I don't end up with 22 Tigers players on field.

Agree that the draw helps too.

[jumbo]

it's raining cats and dogs in Adelaide right now and is going to be a shocking night. Disposal efficiency will be well down I reckon. I'm not confident more than two blokes will go over 100 tonight.

Therefore Rance this week!