WTF - Round 12 (Who to Field)

[GoLions]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

Agreed.  Take the safer option.

Ciaran Byrne v Samuel Collins?

Tough one, that 112 from Byrne has brought up his average, only the 3 scores above 67 and he's averaging almost 70 from 8 games. Might be worth taking the risk on Collins.

Yeah I tend to agree with you GL, other option is to trade Byrne for McVeigh and field him.  Though not sure it;s worth the trade considering Byrne has another price rise in him and could swap for Rance in R14

Rance probably the better option, I brought in McVeigh a few weeks ago and wishing I got Rance instead :-\

[djbics]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

Agreed.  Take the safer option.

Ciaran Byrne v Samuel Collins?

Tough one, that 112 from Byrne has brought up his average, only the 3 scores above 67 and he's averaging almost 70 from 8 games. Might be worth taking the risk on Collins.

Yeah I tend to agree with you GL, other option is to trade Byrne for McVeigh and field him.  Though not sure it;s worth the trade considering Byrne has another price rise in him and could swap for Rance in R14

Rance probably the better option, I brought in McVeigh a few weeks ago and wishing I got Rance instead :-\

Thanks mate, gone Collins for this week, will pick up Rance in Round 14

[RaisyDaisy]

Already fielded Collins  :'(

Byrne vs Lee ?

[tommy10]

Already fielded Collins  :'(

Byrne vs Lee ?

Byrne

Smith or Hopper? Leaning towards Smith...

[GoLions]

Already fielded Collins  :'(

Byrne vs Lee ?

Byrne

Smith or Hopper? Leaning towards Smith...

Yeah agree re: Byrne

I'm going Hopper over Smith

[thebrock]

I have Wagner, Gawn and Cox's bench score vs my opponent 131 points + Pendles.

We both have Petracca on the field atm - anyone think i chance things by throwing Smith on instead?