WTF - Round 12 (Who to Field)

[essendon2]

Hopper v Davis v Petracca

[fanTCfool]

Hopper v Davis v Petracca

Petracca from Davis from Hopper

[Bones Bombers]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Lycett vs Petracca? Playing Truck gives me cover in the rucks if a late out - looking at you Goldy...

I think with what has happened with Goldy, and the doubts on NicNat (if you have him), I'd go with Petracca. If you don't have NicNat, then I'd go with Lycett I reckon.

Who is your R/F switch player? Mine is Wyatt from the Pies. With Wyatt and Truck playing Monday I can easily make the switch with Lycett if Goldy or Nic Nat are out. Hopefully both aren't!

[js19]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Lycett vs Petracca? Playing Truck gives me cover in the rucks if a late out - looking at you Goldy...

I think with what has happened with Goldy, and the doubts on NicNat (if you have him), I'd go with Petracca. If you don't have NicNat, then I'd go with Lycett I reckon.

Who is your R/F switch player? Mine is Wyatt from the Pies. With Wyatt and Truck playing Monday I can easily make the switch with Lycett if Goldy or Nic Nat are out. Hopefully both aren't!

Unfortunately Grimley, so have to make the call tonight. Don't have NicNat, so might roll the dice that Goldy is playing

[Bones Bombers]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Lycett vs Petracca? Playing Truck gives me cover in the rucks if a late out - looking at you Goldy...

I think with what has happened with Goldy, and the doubts on NicNat (if you have him), I'd go with Petracca. If you don't have NicNat, then I'd go with Lycett I reckon.

Who is your R/F switch player? Mine is Wyatt from the Pies. With Wyatt and Truck playing Monday I can easily make the switch with Lycett if Goldy or Nic Nat are out. Hopefully both aren't!

Unfortunately Grimley, so have to make the call tonight. Don't have NicNat, so might roll the dice that Goldy is playing

Ok. I'm almost 100% certain Goldy will play and of course play well.

[mzunguman]

Smith/Hopper/Dunkley???

[js19]

Smith/Hopper/Dunkley???

I'd play Smith > Hopper > Dunkley

[GoLions]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

[LF]

Which one Tucker or Collins on for Adams

[Bones Bombers]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

[Ringo]

Would go Collins LF Collins is more the rebounding defender whereas Tucker is KPP.

[djbics]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

Agreed.  Take the safer option.

Ciaran Byrne v Samuel Collins?

[King_Robbo]

Would go Collins LF Collins is more the rebounding defender whereas Tucker is KPP.

Don't you mean the opposites?

[GoLions]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

Agreed.  Take the safer option.

Ciaran Byrne v Samuel Collins?

Tough one, that 112 from Byrne has brought up his average, only the 3 scores above 67 and he's averaging almost 70 from 8 games. Might be worth taking the risk on Collins.

[djbics]

DBJ vs Petracca, leaning towards Petracca

I'd say Truck

Ok so now with Adams out, it is still DBJ vs Petracca, buttt

If I field Petracca, that means I have Adams and Menadue both on my fwd bench (so zero cover essentially), with DBJ and Collins on my def bench

If I field DBJ, then I have Adams and Collins on def bench (so Collins cover), and Petracca and Menadue on fwd bench (Petracca as cover)

I feel like DBJ is now the safer option, but think Petracca could tear it up against the Pies :-\

Yep you've got it worked out. Keep the cover in case of more late outs.

Agreed.  Take the safer option.

Ciaran Byrne v Samuel Collins?

Tough one, that 112 from Byrne has brought up his average, only the 3 scores above 67 and he's averaging almost 70 from 8 games. Might be worth taking the risk on Collins.

Yeah I tend to agree with you GL, other option is to trade Byrne for McVeigh and field him.  Though not sure it;s worth the trade considering Byrne has another price rise in him and could swap for Rance in R14