Round 12 trades

[tor01doc]

is trading sam mitchell a waste? been 6 weeks of tortue :/

BE 77 and playing Essendon. Should smash it with 46 possies, 3 of which will be contested.

This is your 'line in the sand' moment sammy123.

Hold.

[sammy123]

is trading sam mitchell a waste? been 6 weeks of tortue :/

BE 77 and playing Essendon. Should smash it with 46 possies, 3 of which will be contested.

This is your 'line in the sand' moment sammy123.

Hold.

thanks doc

[Chonks]

Ruggles > Boyd
Macpherson > Neale

[King_Robbo]

All but locked in

Byrne >> Collins
Hewett >> Rocky

Current team is:

Bartel, Simpson, Shaw, Smith, DBJ, Adams - Byrne, Brand
Ablett, Dangerfield, Pendles, Parker, Wines, Libba, Gray, Hopper - Petracca, Smith, Hewett
Goldy, Gawn - Wyatt
Martin, Zorko, Lids, Wells, Hall, Kerridge - Tipa, M.Brown

Giving Byrne the chop a week early than I would like but as I want to keep M.Brown as a playing forward/defensive swingman as I plan to keep Adams in the back line all year. M.Brown can sit at f8 with Petracca at f7

The other option was one of Hall or Wines to Rocky/Selwood and then Brand to Collins..

[GoTheEagles]

Dahlhaus and Ward in next week while Laird after the bye

[GoTheEagles]

Is Gary Ablett a must in?

[tor01doc]

Is Gary Ablett a must in?

Yes.

[Raiden]

DBJ -> Lee (this guy is going to come in sooner rather than later and if not this week then he's a perfect loophole)

and

Smith -> Rocky

Same trades

[tor01doc]

I've got one...

Which is better?

1: Hanners and Smith with 98K

or

2: Hall and Ward (Gibbs or Cotchin) with 40K


NB Hall and Smith already in my team - just a matter of who I trade out. So if  trade Hall I play Smith but can get Hanners.

If I trade Smith, I play Hall and grab one of Ward, Gibbs or Cotchspud.

[plumdog millionaire]

I've got one...

Which is better?

1: Hanners and Smith with 98K

or

2: Hall and Ward (Gibbs or Cotchin) with 40K


NB Hall and Smith already in my team - just a matter of who I trade out. So if  trade Hall I play Smith but can get Hanners.

If I trade Smith, I play Hall and grab one of Ward, Gibbs or Cotchspud.

If it's Josh Smith then 1.

[tor01doc]

I've got one...

Which is better?

1: Hanners and Smith with 98K

or

2: Hall and Ward (Gibbs or Cotchin) with 40K


NB Hall and Smith already in my team - just a matter of who I trade out. So if  trade Hall I play Smith but can get Hanners.

If I trade Smith, I play Hall and grab one of Ward, Gibbs or Cotchspud.

If it's Josh Smith then 1.

Yes, pdm, it would mean trading out Hall for Hanners and playing Josh Smith (or Ryan Davis) on field.

I think I like this better with 5 round averages 15 points per week in favour of Hanners over Ward - and Cotchin and Gibbs just don't appeal.

[GCSkiwi]

I've got one...

Which is better?

1: Hanners and Smith with 98K

or

2: Hall and Ward (Gibbs or Cotchin) with 40K


NB Hall and Smith already in my team - just a matter of who I trade out. So if  trade Hall I play Smith but can get Hanners.

If I trade Smith, I play Hall and grab one of Ward, Gibbs or Cotchspud.

Look at the other side of the picture: If you get rid of Hall, how/when will you be looking to ditch Smith? And vice versa? Don't think there's much in it points wise really but I back Hanners over Ward so my preference is option 1...

[Ringo]

Brown to Collins and depending on Teams announced Ruggles to McVeigh (only if he or Brand not named as no cover) Rance/Lairdother options but McVeigh with the lower B/e.
If Ruggles or Brand named Cox to Tippett,

[Grufflez]

Brown to Collins and depending on Teams announced Ruggles to McVeigh (only if he or Brand not named as no cover) Rance/Lairdother options but McVeigh with the lower B/e.
If Ruggles or Brand named Cox to Tippett,

What are your thoughts on Jansen?
Will Jansen,Keays & Matho be rotated through?

[Ringo]

That is my feeling Gruffelz will not surprise to see Keays rested this week and bring Mattho back who was our best in NEAFL on the weekend. Jansen should get a fair crack though for a while.