Aaron Hall - to keep or to chop

[Raiden]

is he even playing midfield? didnt watch the game. considering trade.

Annoying...only played midfield in the 4th quarter, but chopped up when he was there...Eade hates him it seems.

I was under the impression he played Mid the whole game, came home strong in the 4th qrt which explains it now - Let's hope he get's 4 qrt's in the Mids next week.

[_wato]

Kerridge -> Hall nets $40k

Bloke who at best avg's 85, v bloke at best who avg's 105+

No brainer. Gonna sit at F6/7 so loophole option anyway.

Allows me to bring in heater for Rich in two weeks.

Watched the game and he grew as it wore on. Think he could be a good gamble.
And really, only had the two poor weeks. Rd 10/11 where his shoulder was no good and then had a rest, smashed neafl and now back. He played 83 min tog on the weekend and went at 0.9ppm, he plays 100 mins and get gets close to 90-100
With the soft draw upcoming he could kill it.

[Holz]

Kerridge -> Hall nets $40k

Bloke who at best avg's 85, v bloke at best who avg's 105+

No brainer. Gonna sit at F6/7 so loophole option anyway.

Allows me to bring in heater for Rich in two weeks.

Watched the game and he grew as it wore on. Think he could be a good gamble.

hold up so you sell a guy who has gone

105 68 126 81  81

for

95 84 68 52 71

at the cost of 45 grand.    

total waste of a trade you either trade kerridge to a super premo like Monty Nroo Lids or you downgrade him. Dont use a trae and 45k to bring in a guy who is worse.

[_wato]

Some of us Holz are in need of cash without changing the team structure a whole lot.

If I go Kerridge -> Hall, I can then go Trengove -> rook, Rich -> Heater, Tracca -> Dahl.

Without that extra $45g I keep Petracca and lose Kerridge to Dahl anyway. If Hall can turn it around I wait on Dahl go worst performing mid -> Neale and I maximise points that way.

Final team will be sound.

Dochers Shaw Laird Rance Bartel Simmo
Ablett Pendles Danger Hanners Titch Sloane Shiel Rocky
Goldy Gawn
Dusty Zorko Merrett Buddy Joey Dahl Hall F7/M9

[_wato]

Hall may be worse but he's averaging better than Kerridge and I have spoken about his worst two weeks (52,68) with reason and other than that has gone 129, 124, 134, 114, 90, 76, 95, 84, 71 (in 83 mins)

Not one terrible score in that at all. Even in the weeks where people were hating him his worst wasn't even that bad. Hell a 52 against the premiers with a bung shoulder and then getting dropped to find form is not the worst thing possible.

Kerridge
86, 106, 65, 78, 115, 65, 82, 67, 105, 68, 126, 81, 81 (4 below 68 in that, no injuries and been able to find form)

Hall finding form and getting ball could be scary good. Kerridge ppm is only 0.8 he just plays a lot of tog to get handy scores. Hall averages 1.0ppm so actuslly scores better on field. Is an elite runner as you say so as the season wears on and GC players start to get tired Hall will dominate. Think his upside is 20 points over Kerridge.

[Jimmykidd]

you can break it down how ever you like. the fact is omera will be back soon and i see hall playing permanent half forward like he did on the weekend.

he is a major concern going forward into finals IMO.

but in saying that, im really not in a position to be trading him. 8 trades left and carrying dahl and wells. zorko should be back next week.

he is too cheap now. to get someone even remotely good it will take a lot of cash. just gonna have to hold him.

[Holz]

Some of us Holz are in need of cash without changing the team structure a whole lot.

If I go Kerridge -> Hall, I can then go Trengove -> rook, Rich -> Heater, Tracca -> Dahl.

Without that extra $45g I keep Petracca and lose Kerridge to Dahl anyway. If Hall can turn it around I wait on Dahl go worst performing mid -> Neale and I maximise points that way.

Final team will be sound.

Dochers Shaw Laird Rance Bartel Simmo
Ablett Pendles Danger Hanners Titch Sloane Shiel Rocky
Goldy Gawn
Dusty Zorko Merrett Buddy Joey Dahl Hall F7/M9

Lynch gives you more cash and is a better loophole

has gone consistently big when not playing a strong side. his poor scores are against GWS, Crows, Eagles, Sydney, North, Cats.

against teams not in the 8 he has gone

99 129 112 114 122 116 and has saint kilda then the lions the next 2 weeks in fact in the last 9 weeks they only play finals teams twice.

[_wato]

Only problem is Lynch not a fwd/mid.

I will keep a close eye on Hall but will hold on the trade.

Plenty of others I will also keep a close eye on. Motlop at $377k potentially.

[Holz]

Only problem is Lynch not a fwd/mid.

I will keep a close eye on Hall but will hold on the trade.

Plenty of others I will also keep a close eye on. Motlop at $377k potentially.

yes but dont you have other F/M so if your missing a mid then swing Dustin Martin there and play Lynch.

lynch emergency loophole only really works with forwards unless you have a weak m8 which you dont

[_wato]

Only problem is Lynch not a fwd/mid.

I will keep a close eye on Hall but will hold on the trade.

Plenty of others I will also keep a close eye on. Motlop at $377k potentially.

yes but dont you have other F/M so if your missing a mid then swing Dustin Martin there and play Lynch.

lynch emergency loophole only really works with forwards unless you have a weak m8 which you dont

True didn't think about that. However with Lynch he has amazing and then has terrible. I'd hate to have to field him when he scores <50. I've made another trade which many would think is sideways and youd question but it gets me even more $$ and is a like for like player with further upside. Doesn't upset team at all.

Luke Parker at $465k is the man.

[Holz]

Only problem is Lynch not a fwd/mid.

I will keep a close eye on Hall but will hold on the trade.

Plenty of others I will also keep a close eye on. Motlop at $377k potentially.

yes but dont you have other F/M so if your missing a mid then swing Dustin Martin there and play Lynch.

lynch emergency loophole only really works with forwards unless you have a weak m8 which you dont

True didn't think about that. However with Lynch he has amazing and then has terrible. I'd hate to have to field him when he scores <50. I've made another trade which many would think is sideways and youd question but it gets me even more $$ and is a like for like player with further upside. Doesn't upset team at all.

Luke Parker at $465k is the man.

Sam Mitchell 451K

[King_Robbo]

Only problem is Lynch not a fwd/mid.

I will keep a close eye on Hall but will hold on the trade.

Plenty of others I will also keep a close eye on. Motlop at $377k potentially.

yes but dont you have other F/M so if your missing a mid then swing Dustin Martin there and play Lynch.

lynch emergency loophole only really works with forwards unless you have a weak m8 which you dont

True didn't think about that. However with Lynch he has amazing and then has terrible. I'd hate to have to field him when he scores <50. I've made another trade which many would think is sideways and youd question but it gets me even more $$ and is a like for like player with further upside. Doesn't upset team at all.

Luke Parker at $465k is the man.

Sam Mitchell 451K

I agree with Holz on this one. Smitchell represents incredible value this week, especially at m9 if you have funds. Only worry is getting rested but he's shown in the past that when he gets on a run he can go 120s for a month or so. Well worth it at his price

[tttt]

Woukdnt you want a fwd/mid dpp at m9/f7?
thinking of keeping hall for that, he's shown that when hes on, he can go huge

[Jimmykidd]

i've had mitchell since round 5 lol. its nice he has finally scored well. i'd stay away, he'll likely get rested in SC finals.

[hogan2014]

[/quote]

Sam Mitchell 451K
[/quote]
Mitchell is 487k now but sure is a bargain.
30k makes all the diffenance to me unfortunatley so can't get him next week.