Aaron Hall - to keep or to chop

Started by King_Robbo, June 05, 2016, 02:05:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Torpedo10

If you were to trade him it should've been when he was at top dollar.

You must hold now, at least until the byes. He may well explode again and give you a couple of 100s after the byes to give you some more value.

Bully

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on June 07, 2016, 06:19:23 PM
I started with him, and I am happy with what he gave me, but now I would like to trade him out but just don't have that luxury so he stays for now, and I will loophole him where possible

Sucks for those who brought him in 3-4 weeks into the season though

If I can get through the byes and still have 4-6 trades left, then I will dump him

Can't complain about 96 avg for a tick over 400k. However, the time to cut and run is now, no question, particularly with so many other cheap forwards available.

plumdog millionaire

I believe in not selling low, and I know I've likely missed the boat, but I'm going to wait until he appreciates a bit and die by that sword

js19

The fact I'll be starting Kerridge over him this week means it's time to go! No point having him if he's on the bench

dottman

I intend to keep him or Kerrige as m9\f7 just not sure which 1.

timtim

Quote from: dottman on June 07, 2016, 07:41:03 PM
I intend to keep him or Kerrige as m9\f7 just not sure which 1.

Same here

Will make the call when push comes to shove - will try and keep both as along as possible.

Also keeping Brown for DEF/FWD swing so not to fussed that he's bleeding cash

MontyJnr

I'd hate to drop him now only for him to tear it up against the Tigers in a game that isn't at Subi or in torrential rain.

One last chance before his bye. I'm happy to risk the price drop.

Goosey

Quote from: timtim on June 07, 2016, 09:52:36 PM
Quote from: dottman on June 07, 2016, 07:41:03 PM
I intend to keep him or Kerrige as m9\f7 just not sure which 1.

Same here

Will make the call when push comes to shove - will try and keep both as along as possible.

Also keeping Brown for DEF/FWD swing so not to fussed that he's bleeding cash
Too much cash sitting on the bench for my liking. I have already cut Hall, Kerridge will be on the block soon, but he's still appreciating so might last a couple of weeks yet!

AaronKirk

IMO it comes down to how many rookies on field you have left. I only have 2 so want to upgrade those spots ASAP and then look at luxury trades. I have 15 trades left so I helps a in that aspect. I'm holding for now.

Holz

Quote from: AaronKirk on June 08, 2016, 03:05:59 AM
IMO it comes down to how many rookies on field you have left. I only have 2 so want to upgrade those spots ASAP and then look at luxury trades. I have 15 trades left so I helps a in that aspect. I'm holding for now.

What rookies are thry though?

AaronKirk

Quote from: Holz on June 08, 2016, 09:58:04 AM
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 08, 2016, 03:05:59 AM
IMO it comes down to how many rookies on field you have left. I only have 2 so want to upgrade those spots ASAP and then look at luxury trades. I have 15 trades left so I helps a in that aspect. I'm holding for now.

What rookies are thry though?

Dea and Petracca. Want to keep Petracca for the byes now but will be upgrading Dea next week.

Holz

Quote from: AaronKirk on June 08, 2016, 10:16:58 AM
Quote from: Holz on June 08, 2016, 09:58:04 AM
Quote from: AaronKirk on June 08, 2016, 03:05:59 AM
IMO it comes down to how many rookies on field you have left. I only have 2 so want to upgrade those spots ASAP and then look at luxury trades. I have 15 trades left so I helps a in that aspect. I'm holding for now.

What rookies are thry though?

Dea and Petracca. Want to keep Petracca for the byes now but will be upgrading Dea next week.

ok upgrading dea makes sense.

Petracca seems a better hold then Hall though.


100 51 89 in the last 3

PICCOLLO

Couldnt find room for dahl, now I can.

Im only fielding one rookie and dont have any other fish to fry. I guess you are gone Hall.

Shame to waste my cash reserves on you but youre injured, havent put up classy numbers in a while, youre playing in a team that gets pumped every week and you could get rested without notice. Shoulder injuries are a worry as tackles are a good source of points in weaker teams.

Would rather keep you but cant find enough reason to.

Jimmykidd

Back to back 20 disposal games. Didn't attend 1 centre bounce. Not ONE.

In his defense, he was getting a lot of disposals in those lower scoring games, but they weren't translating to good SC scores. Now he is just useless.

You either cut him now, or have him as bench cover. I think he has to go.  Either this week or round 14

quinny88

Keep in mind GC play Richmond this week.. I reckon we are the #1 team for running average players into form so expect a 120  :-X