Aaron Hall - to keep or to chop

[Capper]

Yes his scores of late havent been the best but his ave is still over 96.

The biggest concern is his shoulder as he isnt tackling or lining up in the middle for centre bouncers (0 against Swans) but conditions were horrendous at the Gold Coast especially when you cant tackle due to shoulder issues.

I can see the Suns resting him for an extra week over the bye period if they have enough troops to cover his spot.

Out of Kerridge, Adams and Hall, i would get rid of Adams first as he has been playing as a key defender.

[Bully]

Out of Kerridge, Adams and Hall, i would get rid of Adams first as he has been playing as a key defender.

Adams still has money to make, and besides he can be switched back into defence where he's excellent injury cover. I can understand people holding but fortunately I don't have any priorities this week and want to bring Zorko into the team. There's far too many value prospects coming up which makes it even harder to justify hanging on to a guy who may or may not play out the season. I can see myself trading in Dahlhaus, Deledio & Joey over the next few weeks, all of whom should easily outscore Hall.

[Holz]

I reckon he has to go,

wasnt putting up premo numbers before the injury and now he is really below par. Best i can see is he comes back to full health and puts up 85-90.

only thing is, its almost too late, he is dropped 100k and not worth much more then some of the best rookies.

I would trade him out of kerridge adams though.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm stuck with him. Already getting low on trades and struggling to get 22 prems with trades left over

I'll loophole Hall, Petracca and Sinclair each week where possible

Luxury upgrade after the byes if I can afford it

[Bully]

I reckon he has to go,

wasnt putting up premo numbers before the injury and now he is really below par. Best i can see is he comes back to full health and puts up 85-90.

only thing is, its almost too late, he is dropped 100k and not worth much more then some of the best rookies.

I would trade him out of kerridge adams though.

This is the week to ditch him, can still make hay with so many other blue ribbon forwards having dipped in price.

Hall + 80k = Dahlhaus,
Hall + 60k = Joey
Hall + 100k = Lids

These numbers aren't too dissimilar to a few weeks back when Hall was fully priced. Leave it any longer and Hall goes sub 400k and becomes very hard to shift. 

[GoLions]

Very glad I kept Barlow instead of trading him to Hall!

[Hazza09]

Is Hall worth keeping as a floating M9/F7?

In my opinion he isn't worth it...Kerridge can do that role easily.

i have 15 trades left and am very unsure if Hall needs to be traded.

[Raiden]

I guess we can't read to much into this Herald Sun commentary, but who know's what Eade is thinking - I need him to at least hang around for the Bye rounds.

ON THE BLOCK: Rodney Eade said after the loss to Sydney in atrocious weather at Metricon Stadium that 21 of his 22 players could hold their heads high. He didn’t name the one player in his sights but it could only be Aaron Hall who just refused to put his head over the ball.

[Holz]

I guess we can't read to much into this Herald Sun commentary, but who know's what Eade is thinking - I need him to at least hang around for the Bye rounds.

ON THE BLOCK: Rodney Eade said after the loss to Sydney in atrocious weather at Metricon Stadium that 21 of his 22 players could hold their heads high. He didn’t name the one player in his sights but it could only be Aaron Hall who just refused to put his head over the ball.

could it Tom Lynch after he got reported?

[Raiden]

Yeah I'm hoping so.

[shaker]

I'm stuck with him. Already getting low on trades and struggling to get 22 prems with trades left over

I'll loophole Hall, Petracca and Sinclair each week where possible

Luxury upgrade after the byes if I can afford it

Yep me too but that is not to bad have the luxury of benching him and maybe even some loopholes down the track but trades are becoming precious so he stays and who knows if the Suns can get some more players back and he gets over his shoulder maybe he can hit the SC score board again  ;)

[Jimmykidd]

if you have the trades to axe him then go ahead. i have 15 and im not wasting one on a guy who has so much potential.

[MontyJnr]

I would still get rid of Kerridge before Hall. Everyone forgets that Kerridge put up a 60 against Geelong just 2 weeks ago, probably because they forgive him for being a 'rookie' pick.

[Holz]

I would still get rid of Kerridge before Hall. Everyone forgets that Kerridge put up a 60 against Geelong just 2 weeks ago, probably because they forgive him for being a 'rookie' pick.

I cant say im unbias in this convo but last 7 weeks.

90 76 95 84 0 68 52 v

115 62 82 67 105 68 126

kerridge is up and down but still averaging 89 in that period. Ill take that over 77.

Kerridge is a great F7 M9 link aswell.

[tor01doc]

I would still get rid of Kerridge before Hall. Everyone forgets that Kerridge put up a 60 against Geelong just 2 weeks ago, probably because they forgive him for being a 'rookie' pick.

Player         DPP       Price this week    Projected next week        BE          3 round ave             5 Round ave   

Hall               F/M      413K                     409K                        138                 68                          75           

Kerridge        F/M      417K                     430K                          56                100                         90         


I know who I'd keep.