Aaron Hall - to keep or to chop

[StuL]

I'm thinking of trading Trengove (disaster of a pick) to Clay Smith.

Have to play Menadue and Hipwood in my forward line otherwise as I also have Deledio out.

Only 1 trade left if I get Smith in.

Is it worth it?

I just figure you'll need more than 2 trades in the last 6 weeks. Save them now til you NEED them.

[NickyBoy]

Have to keep Hall for now. I have 2 upgrades left in my side and only 6 trades left  :-\

[Judd Magic]

I'm thinking of trading Trengove (disaster of a pick) to Clay Smith.

Have to play Menadue and Hipwood in my forward line otherwise as I also have Deledio out.

Only 1 trade left if I get Smith in.

Is it worth it?

I just figure you'll need more than 2 trades in the last 6 weeks. Save them now til you NEED them.

Yeah you are most likely right mate.

Guess I will hold my 2 trades this week and just suck up the carnage.   :-X

[King_Robbo]

Surely you hold. Not sure his time frame but if you can cover why waste a trade?
I have good old Mitch brown on my bench at f8... Not the whole rest week to play him either vs lions

[smashbox]

Hammy would usually be 3-4 weeks. Cant really be carrying him that long

[RaisyDaisy]

Hammy would usually be 3-4 weeks. Cant really be carrying him that long

If he actually did his hammy, but we don't know

Might just be tightness

Holding this week, and holding Lids too. Make the call next week

[King_Robbo]

Hammy would usually be 3-4 weeks. Cant really be carrying him that long

Do we know if he's actually given it a twang or if it's a slight strain?
Could just be a 1-2 week injury. I'm holding as I would rather use my trades on season ending injuries

[enzedder]

Until I know more will be keeping him...same as Lids... will be playing Petracca and Markov (on extended bench but should play).

[Maca24]

Does anyone have a time frame on him?

[TomK]

Listed as TBC on the AFL injury list so I guess we won't know more til next week.

[russty]

I'm in a cash league and I'm part of the log jam for the last couple of finals spots so I don't want to cop a donut.

4 trades left, trading Hall leaves me with $450k. Not much on offer at this price.

I've narrowed it down to  - C Smith, Kerridge, Wingard and JJK. Don't think I've left anyone out.

I'm leaning towards Smith, can he be trusted to play all games? This will leave me with $156k to.

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm in a cash league and I'm part of the log jam for the last couple of finals spots so I don't want to cop a donut.

4 trades left, trading Hall leaves me with $450k. Not much on offer at this price.

I've narrowed it down to  - C Smith, Kerridge, Wingard and JJK. Don't think I've left anyone out.

I'm leaning towards Smith, can he be trusted to play all games? This will leave me with $156k to.

I assume you already have Toby Greene?

Do you have a mid that you can move forward and then bring in Gaff or Crouch?

[russty]

Hmm forgot about Greene, nah don't have him. You would go with him would ya?

Nah don't have a mid that I can move forward.

[RaisyDaisy]

Hmm forgot about Greene, nah don't have him. You would go with him would ya?

Nah don't have a mid that I can move forward.

I'm holding Hall personally as I need to hold the trade, but out of those options I would probably take Greene above those 4

[LF]

Just read that Hall not likely back until Round 21

http://www.goldcoastfc.com.au/news/2016-07-22/injury-update-aaron-hall