Darcy Tucker versus Bailey Williams

[MC]

Given my bye situation, I don't think I can afford to grab Tucker/Collins!  :o

Have 9 prems out in rd 15, as well as Mathieson & Brand who will be sketchy as far as value for trading out, plus designated donut Goetz.

Barlow may need to be moved on at some stage I guess, but otherwise the way it's looking i'll have only 18 players who will play rd 15...
Getting Collins or Tucker will reduce that further!

[RaisyDaisy]

Given my bye situation, I don't think I can afford to grab Tucker/Collins!  :o

Have 9 prems out in rd 15, as well as Mathieson & Brand who will be sketchy as far as value for trading out, plus designated donut Goetz.

Barlow may need to be moved on at some stage I guess, but otherwise the way it's looking i'll have only 18 players who will play rd 15...
Getting Collins or Tucker will reduce that further!

I know it's far from a guarantee, but if Tucker holds his spot you could trade him out prior to Rd15 and he would get 4 price rises before then

[MontyJnr]

Can't believe this got its own thread!! :o

Tucker vs Collins is the real big decision!

[Bully]

Can't believe this got its own thread!! :o

Tucker vs Collins is the real big decision!

Most coaches will have both by next week.

[js19]

Can't believe this got its own thread!! :o

Tucker vs Collins is the real big decision!

Most coaches will have both by next week.

Only if you don't have Brand already stuck on the bench I'd say...

Wouldn't want either of them D6, but bench is fine I reckon

[no eye deer]

Can't believe this got its own thread!! :o

Tucker vs Collins is the real big decision!

Most coaches will have both by next week.

Only if you don't have Brand already stuck on the bench I'd say...

Wouldn't want either of them D6, but bench is fine I reckon

This is my dilemma

[js19]

Can't believe this got its own thread!! :o

Tucker vs Collins is the real big decision!

Most coaches will have both by next week.

Only if you don't have Brand already stuck on the bench I'd say...

Wouldn't want either of them D6, but bench is fine I reckon

This is my dilemma

Yeah, 3 guys with shaky JS and limited scoring is risky. If they get dropped or cash generations stagnates you could end up needing a double down, or a 400k downgrade somewhere just to finish the Ds, let alone the lack of cover...

[Holz]

Collins other both. Should play every game. Mature ager in a role they needed.

Is a good intercept mark and should be a decent scorer. Have been monitoring since he got picked up, kids very good.

Unless lyon stuffs up i reckon he plays every game maybe rest 1-2 and averages 60.

Tucker can average more but not as solid js. Think he could be in trouble when ibbo back.

[gracey89]

Collins other both. Should play every game. Mature ager in a role they needed.

Is a good intercept mark and should be a decent scorer. Have been monitoring since he got picked up, kids very good.

Unless lyon stuffs up i reckon he plays every game maybe rest 1-2 and averages 60.

Tucker can average more but not as solid js. Think he could be in trouble when ibbo back.

Ibbo is out for atleast 4 weeks. I personally am getting Tucker this week and then Collins next week for ruggles.

[RaisyDaisy]

Collins other both. Should play every game. Mature ager in a role they needed.

Is a good intercept mark and should be a decent scorer. Have been monitoring since he got picked up, kids very good.

Unless lyon stuffs up i reckon he plays every game maybe rest 1-2 and averages 60.

Tucker can average more but not as solid js. Think he could be in trouble when ibbo back.

I'm looking at getting Tucker this week and Collins next week, but I am wary of them adding to already plenty RD15 bye players I will have

I would also be left with one of them at D6 for a while, which I don't see a problem with but it would take some time before they could be upgraded which needs to be considered too.

Struggling to figure out which way to go

[Jimmykidd]

i have brand and its the only thing stopping me from getting them both. collins is the better pick IMO. lets not forget Tucker was out for 4 rounds and only came back in because of injury. theres no way im playing one of these guys on the field either (downgrading fbj/adams to tucker/collins) is not an option.

[Holz]

Collins other both. Should play every game. Mature ager in a role they needed.

Is a good intercept mark and should be a decent scorer. Have been monitoring since he got picked up, kids very good.

Unless lyon stuffs up i reckon he plays every game maybe rest 1-2 and averages 60.

Tucker can average more but not as solid js. Think he could be in trouble when ibbo back.

Ibbo is out for atleast 4 weeks. I personally am getting Tucker this week and then Collins next week for ruggles.

its not just ibbo though, playing essendon you dont need that many key defenders. If they need big men then a guy like uberang could be in.

[Jimmykidd]

Collins other both. Should play every game. Mature ager in a role they needed.

Is a good intercept mark and should be a decent scorer. Have been monitoring since he got picked up, kids very good.

Unless lyon stuffs up i reckon he plays every game maybe rest 1-2 and averages 60.

Tucker can average more but not as solid js. Think he could be in trouble when ibbo back.

Ibbo is out for atleast 4 weeks. I personally am getting Tucker this week and then Collins next week for ruggles.

its not just ibbo though, playing essendon you dont need that many key defenders. If they need big men then a guy like uberang could be in.

C. Pearce didnt get up from concussion this week so I'd say tucker would be straight out for him next week. cash generation is key, yes, but at what cost..

[RaisyDaisy]

Starting to think I might pass on Tucker and just go a week early on Collins

I know Tucker is rated as a player, but his JS is questionable and his bye is a killer

[Jimmykidd]

Starting to think I might pass on Tucker and just go a week early on Collins

I know Tucker is rated as a player, but his JS is questionable and his bye is a killer

would wait another week if you can. it is ross lyon after all..