Boyd or rance

[rfc4eva]

Cant decide on who to trade adams for

[Holz]

I would always go the younger guy if both are likely to average the same. Also Boyd has just been playing at etihad where the dogs are fantastic that ends now as he is playing at MCG and they will start leaving melbourne soon. That spells drop in scoring and restings.

[LordSneeze]

With the amount of outs in the bulldogs defence I cannot see Boyd getting much of a rest this year. Should be a top 6 defender too.
Rance I want to see a little more from especially with the way Richmond are going.

[tor01doc]

Hold Adams?

Rance if I had to choose.

[Holz]

With the amount of outs in the bulldogs defence I cannot see Boyd getting much of a rest this year. Should be a top 6 defender too.
Rance I want to see a little more from especially with the way Richmond are going.

Tigers have sucked all year. if anything that are improving with lids back in. Rance to me is the best defender in the AFL happy to back him in after 95 last year.

Boyd will have to be rested at some stage, they are going for a flag. Not sure making a guy who will turn 34 this year play 22 isnt smart management. He is a rebounder not a lock down defender i think they can find a guy to do that 1 week. What richmond cant do is rest its best defender (best in the AFL)

[Gigantor]

With the amount of outs in the bulldogs defence I cannot see Boyd getting much of a rest this year. Should be a top 6 defender too.
Rance I want to see a little more from especially with the way Richmond are going.

Tigers have sucked all year. if anything that are improving with lids back in. Rance to me is the best defender in the AFL happy to back him in after 95 last year.

Boyd will have to be rested at some stage, they are going for a flag. Not sure making a guy who will turn 34 this year play 22 isnt smart management. He is a rebounder not a lock down defender i think they can find a guy to do that 1 week. What richmond cant do is rest its best defender (best in the AFL)

I agree, Boyd will get a rest potentially next to the Dogs bye when Suckers and JJ are back

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Hold Adams?

Rance if I had to choose.

Corrrrrrrrrrrrrect.  Hold for a few weeks at least.      :) ;) :D

[ronl]

brought in Rance yesterday, hopefully Laird back next week but haven't heard anything definite on that.