Random Theoretical Question to Freo Fans

[GoLions]

come on valk :P

You seriously trying to tell me that Kelly is a better player than Fyfe?

Come on Bill

GL is shower stirring valk

[Toga]

Kelly is clearly better than Fyfe now. The benefits of Leon playing the kids.

Settle down - Fyfe is returning from a broken leg.  I don't see a Brownlow medal around Kelly's neck

Hook, line and sinker

Every time ???

[Holz]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

[Ricochet]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

[Nige]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

I can see it.

[Holz]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

[Ricochet]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

[Nige]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

Excuse you. The ill mind of Holz (and his constant craving too never be wrong about anything ever) >>>> reality.

[GoLions]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

Yeah in the deal between GWS and Freo, you also get Lang because he just felt like he didn't belong at the Cats and the Cats get to not have to pay Lang anymore.

Tbh I don't know why you guys would want Hopper and SPS and all them though. They'd never get a game under Ross.

[Ricochet]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

Yeah in the deal between GWS and Freo, you also get Lang because he just felt like he didn't belong at the Cats and the Cats get to not have to pay Lang anymore.

Tbh I don't know why you guys would want Hopper and SPS and all them though. They'd never get a game under Ross.

Exactly! Maybe in 5-8 years time, but they'd be no chance now

[Nige]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

Yeah in the deal between GWS and Freo, you also get Lang because he just felt like he didn't belong at the Cats and the Cats get to not have to pay Lang anymore.

Tbh I don't know why you guys would want Hopper and SPS and all them though. They'd never get a game under Ross.

Exactly! Maybe in 5-8 years time, but they'd be no chance now

Are we sure Lang wouldn't move across the country despite currently being an hour away from home?

[Holz]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

Mccarthy cost you Glugg or SPS. (But got Lang and Logue)

SPS is a WA boy too.

Yeh you're right, Clugg or SPS out of the square at FF would have been awesome

my trade was McCarthy Kelly and Hopper for Fyfe.

so you get McCarthy regardless.

basically


do you prefer

McCarthy  with Fyfe Lang Logue

or

McCarthy  with Kelly Hopper SPS




Kelly < Fyfe
Hopper >>> Lang
SPS >> Logue

summary Holz trade >>>> reality

Lang??

And way to early to call SPS vs Logue. Come talk to me in 3 years

Logue is also a WA boy and we reaaaally needed a key defender. Going into the draft there was a heap of talk over here that he could even go top 3-5
He is big, strong and has a massive tank. He could be anything

Excuse you. The ill mind of Holz (and his constant craving too never be wrong about anything ever) >>>> reality.

Im often wrong.

Goldy over Witts to start this year
Thinking Neale would regress
I didnt think Kelly was this good, I actually assumed that Hopper would be the guy who delivered more then people expected.

I just like to think im correct more then im incorrect.

nobody gets it right every time, if not they would win SC every year by 2000 points.

I just think you take advantage of opportunity and GWS has too many players so you can probably get a package cheap as they cant play them all and fit all under cap.

The same way because they had academy picks teams could move up the draft cheap as 20 + 50 + 55 was worth more points then say pick 14

even though i think 14 is worth much more then all that.

[Adamant]

Im often wrong.

Goldy over Witts to start this year
Thinking Neale would regress
I didnt think Kelly was this good, I actually assumed that Hopper would be the guy who delivered more then people expected.

Ebert is an 80 average winger.

[Ricochet]

Im often wrong.

Goldy over Witts to start this year
Thinking Neale would regress
I didnt think Kelly was this good, I actually assumed that Hopper would be the guy who delivered more then people expected.

Ebert is an 80 average winger.

Brad is better than Matt

[SydneyRox]

If i had a half empty bag of chips, would you trade it for Bennell?