Random Theoretical Question to Freo Fans

[Holz]

Harrison Macreadie or Josh Rotham seem the obvious choices.

I think I like Macreadie better, the extra 3cm makes a difference IMO.  I just worry that Rotham will turn out a bit like Alex Silvagni.

Another issue is that Macreadie is a GWS academy player, so we have to hope that they dont match our bid (if we bid with our first pick)

Macredie is better but you wont get him. GWS have 5 of the top 20 talents in their academy. Macredie is the best though they wont let him go.

3/5 are outside mids they might let 1-2 of them go and will pick up the key forward.

So yeah Rotham. unless you go a key forward in Josh Battle

[valkorum]

Josh Battle is a bit of a reach at pick #1 (at this stage)

[valkorum]

Lots of KPP available according to this article - none of them seem top 10 worthy though

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-05-17/swans-miss-out-on-academy-prospect-ben-davis?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=RSS+feed%3A+AFL+Latest+News

[anchorman]

I am not sure just where I heard it, but it was said that the draft this year would be the weakest for many years.So if that is true, just what or who is there for the Dockers?

[valkorum]

Definitely seems weak for KPP

[Holz]

Would you guys take a trade of

Josh Kelly (#2 draft pick)
Jacob Hopper (#7 draft picks) but really should have gone top 3
Cam McCarthy (#14 draft pick)

for Nathan Fyfe

I'm a definite no

And that's before considering that we should get McCarthy for not much at the end of the year

So Kelly in pretty great form.

Still wouldn't take the deal?

Kelly in as good as form as Fyfe
Hopper looking decent with 17 touches a game

and instead of Sean Darcy and Griffen Logue you would have McGluggage or SPS.



Kelly Neale Hopper B.Hill S.Hill McGluggage looks like a pretty gun young midfield.

[valkorum]

Still wouldnt take the deal because Kelly and Hopper would both probably want to go home after a few years.  And like I said, we got McCarthy for nothing anyway.

[GoLions]

Kelly is clearly better than Fyfe now. The benefits of Leon playing the kids.

[valkorum]

Kelly is clearly better than Fyfe now. The benefits of Leon playing the kids.

Settle down - Fyfe is returning from a broken leg.  I don't see a Brownlow medal around Kelly's neck

[elephants]

Kelly is clearly better than Fyfe now. The benefits of Leon playing the kids.

Settle down - Fyfe is returning from a broken leg.  I don't see a Brownlow medal around Kelly's neck

Hook, line and sinker

[valkorum]

Don't think so Ele.  Kelly is a good player but he isnt Fyfe and he doesnt get the attention that Fyfe gets.

[Bill Manspeaker]

come on valk :P

[valkorum]

come on valk :P

You seriously trying to tell me that Kelly is a better player than Fyfe?

Come on Bill

[Ricochet]

come on valk :P

You seriously trying to tell me that Kelly is a better player than Fyfe?

Come on Bill

GL is shower stirring valk

[Bill Manspeaker]

come on valk :P

You seriously trying to tell me that Kelly is a better player than Fyfe?

Come on Bill

when they're both in the red white and black I won't care which one is better :P