Round 7 trades.

Started by Sabretooth Tigers, May 01, 2016, 05:49:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Holz

Quote from: _wato on May 03, 2016, 10:55:37 AM
Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 10:42:06 AM
must admit is pretty 50/50

do you worry at all of a fit rocky then beams coming back. They do have alot of ball winners already with the likes of robbo hanley even rich.

for me the edge is dahl as he plays on probably a top 4 team so more wins and more chances to get the ball. Its not like Zorko is carrying a weak team like an ablett a few years back.

he does just keep scoring though.

Nope, not at all. Rocky Beams Zorko probably start on ball, Hanley and Rich outside and then Robbo gives a chop out when he can.
He can go wherever he wants really, was watching the game on the weekend and he was licensed to run literally everywhere Dan Han went so he was always amongst it and hence them both going pretty big. He had 148dt last week, bad de stopped him going 130+

I like Zorko's ceiling a lot more than Dahl's and Zorko hasn't gone under 100 yet. The fear I have with Dahl is the fact that they are so evenly spread the dogs that he could easily just continue to rack over 80 but nothing more and nothing less due to the amount of players that score well on their team. The bigger scores won't come as regularly as Zorko's can and top 4 potential doesn't always mean more ball.

The thing that wins it for me is, take a look at Zorko's last 17 scores and give me his average.

I reckon the answer is get both

Dahl

116 139 92 93 106 136 90 114 97 108 98 87 154 105 103 113

109.4 average from last 16 games with a low of 87.

Zorko

109.8 average from last 17 games with a low of 61 (2nd low is 90+ though)


_wato

Zorko 91, 119, 124, 124, 145, 96, 61, 134, 117, 157, 109, 95, 148, 108, 117, 102, 110

Avg of 115.1 Holz

tor01doc

Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 11:10:30 AM
Quote from: _wato on May 03, 2016, 10:55:37 AM
Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 10:42:06 AM
must admit is pretty 50/50

do you worry at all of a fit rocky then beams coming back. They do have alot of ball winners already with the likes of robbo hanley even rich.

for me the edge is dahl as he plays on probably a top 4 team so more wins and more chances to get the ball. Its not like Zorko is carrying a weak team like an ablett a few years back.

he does just keep scoring though.

Nope, not at all. Rocky Beams Zorko probably start on ball, Hanley and Rich outside and then Robbo gives a chop out when he can.
He can go wherever he wants really, was watching the game on the weekend and he was licensed to run literally everywhere Dan Han went so he was always amongst it and hence them both going pretty big. He had 148dt last week, bad de stopped him going 130+

I like Zorko's ceiling a lot more than Dahl's and Zorko hasn't gone under 100 yet. The fear I have with Dahl is the fact that they are so evenly spread the dogs that he could easily just continue to rack over 80 but nothing more and nothing less due to the amount of players that score well on their team. The bigger scores won't come as regularly as Zorko's can and top 4 potential doesn't always mean more ball.

The thing that wins it for me is, take a look at Zorko's last 17 scores and give me his average.

I reckon the answer is get both

Dahl

116 139 92 93 106 136 90 114 97 108 98 87 154 105 103 113

109.4 average from last 16 games with a low of 87.

Zorko

109.8 average from last 17 games with a low of 61 (2nd low is 90+ though)

So 92 150 127 139 95 98 129 124 134 114 90 76 from last 12 games with a low of 76

114 average isn't good enough hey Holz?

You'd trade this guy out??!!

Fanfooty community waiting for your retraction.

Big Mac


Holz

Quote from: tor01doc on May 03, 2016, 11:24:41 AM
Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 11:10:30 AM
Quote from: _wato on May 03, 2016, 10:55:37 AM
Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 10:42:06 AM
must admit is pretty 50/50

do you worry at all of a fit rocky then beams coming back. They do have alot of ball winners already with the likes of robbo hanley even rich.

for me the edge is dahl as he plays on probably a top 4 team so more wins and more chances to get the ball. Its not like Zorko is carrying a weak team like an ablett a few years back.

he does just keep scoring though.

Nope, not at all. Rocky Beams Zorko probably start on ball, Hanley and Rich outside and then Robbo gives a chop out when he can.
He can go wherever he wants really, was watching the game on the weekend and he was licensed to run literally everywhere Dan Han went so he was always amongst it and hence them both going pretty big. He had 148dt last week, bad de stopped him going 130+

I like Zorko's ceiling a lot more than Dahl's and Zorko hasn't gone under 100 yet. The fear I have with Dahl is the fact that they are so evenly spread the dogs that he could easily just continue to rack over 80 but nothing more and nothing less due to the amount of players that score well on their team. The bigger scores won't come as regularly as Zorko's can and top 4 potential doesn't always mean more ball.

The thing that wins it for me is, take a look at Zorko's last 17 scores and give me his average.

I reckon the answer is get both

Dahl

116 139 92 93 106 136 90 114 97 108 98 87 154 105 103 113

109.4 average from last 16 games with a low of 87.

Zorko

109.8 average from last 17 games with a low of 61 (2nd low is 90+ though)

So 92 150 127 139 95 98 129 124 134 114 90 76 from last 12 games with a low of 76

114 average isn't good enough hey Holz?

You'd trade this guy out??!!

Fanfooty community waiting for your retraction.

that convo is over

we are discussing Dahl a guy who has averaged 91 104 and now up to 110 showing over 2 years of consistent improvement  v Zorko who has averaged 99 or over 3 times and can score very big but is known to throw in some low games.

Dahl probably is more solid with 103 105 113 in last 3
Zorko probably higher ceiling with 117 102 110 in last 3.




JBs-Hawks

Dont know whether too

Kennedy to Smith
Weits to Shaw

or

Kennedy to Smith
Menadue to Cox

Get Shaw at his cheapest or get some ruck coverage?

js19

Smith and Parker (finally...) this week

Truck and Rocky (if he's back to 100+ again) next week. If Rocky fails, Dahl or Ward comes in.

Hazza09

Now with Laird out for 3 weeks this changes everything  :'(

Laird
Weitering

Looks like a premo defender e.g. Boyd or Simpson has to come in

whynot102

Matt Crouch to Smith then Dea to Heath Shaw

mzunguman

Quote from: Hazza09 on May 03, 2016, 02:44:58 PM
Now with Laird out for 3 weeks this changes everything  :'(

Laird
Weitering

Looks like a premo defender e.g. Boyd or Simpson has to come in


mzunguman


Holz

Quote from: Hazza09 on May 03, 2016, 02:44:58 PM
Now with Laird out for 3 weeks this changes everything  :'(

Laird
Weitering

Looks like a premo defender e.g. Boyd or Simpson has to come in

where is he 3 weeks?

im reading artciels 2 hours ago that he is 50/50

3 weeks is great for me as i dont have laird and lots of top coaches do.

sammy123


jvalles69

Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 02:51:36 PM
Quote from: Hazza09 on May 03, 2016, 02:44:58 PM
Now with Laird out for 3 weeks this changes everything  :'(

Laird
Weitering

Looks like a premo defender e.g. Boyd or Simpson has to come in

where is he 3 weeks?

im reading artciels 2 hours ago that he is 50/50

3 weeks is great for me as i dont have laird and lots of top coaches do.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-05-03/tough-break-for-crow-as-laird-faces-three-weeks-out

Holz

Quote from: jvalles69 on May 03, 2016, 02:53:42 PM
Quote from: Holz on May 03, 2016, 02:51:36 PM
Quote from: Hazza09 on May 03, 2016, 02:44:58 PM
Now with Laird out for 3 weeks this changes everything  :'(

Laird
Weitering

Looks like a premo defender e.g. Boyd or Simpson has to come in

where is he 3 weeks?

im reading artciels 2 hours ago that he is 50/50

3 weeks is great for me as i dont have laird and lots of top coaches do.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-05-03/tough-break-for-crow-as-laird-faces-three-weeks-out

thanks 7 of the top 10 have him so thats good news.

I reckon 3 weeks if your going for overall he has to go, league would keep him as he is a gun.