Who to field round 6

Started by Judd Magic, April 26, 2016, 07:47:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Judd Magic

Who to field out of Parish, Ben Kennedy and Petracca?

MAGICALMAGPIES

Quote from: Judd Magic on April 28, 2016, 09:33:46 PM
Who to field out of Parish, Ben Kennedy and Petracca?

Probably Parish for me, should get 80 - 90 from him, BKen a bit off the boil SC wise the last 3 weeks, Petracca we haven't seen yet so who knows? I've had him from the start and debating whether to roll the dice also?

_wato

To choose 3 out of DBJ, Mills, Pap, Tippa, McCarthy?

Big Mac


Mat0369

So with Gray out I have to field an extra rookie. I can swing my team round so I am trying to decide who my better options are. I thought I could loophole for Gray but it turns out that's a no with Menadue, Davis and Hewett all playing the same time or after Port. I've broken it down like this

D4-6 Dea, Weits, Byrne-Jones, Brown, Ruggles
M7-8 Kerridge, Mills, Hewett, Davis, Gray
F3-6 Wells, Kennedy, Adams, Walla, McCarthy, Menadue.

I have swung Hall into the mids and Adams into the forward line. Do any of Brown, Hewett, Davis, McCarthy or Menadue look better then the guys I am starting? I'm thinking I have it pretty right for this week at least. McCarthy is the only one that might be a maybe over Dea but I think Dea holds less risk.

Ringo

Can not fault Matt - McCarthy as you say maybe one but hard to see how to get him on field to improve output.

Raiden

Field Petracca over Menadue?

We haven't seen Petracca play, we know his a gun however Menadue has gone into spud mode recently but could also bounce back against a depleted Port.

I'm leaning on taking a punt with Petracca.

Jimmykidd

mccarthy at home? paps against lions away? kennedy vs saints at etihad?

impossible  ;D

tor01doc

Quote from: Jimmykidd on April 29, 2016, 11:21:02 AM
mccarthy at home? paps against lions away? kennedy vs saints at etihad?

impossible  ;D

Paps > McCarthy > Kennedy but impossible really.

Dea or Hartley?

Thanks

Hazza09

F6 spot between Tippa, B Kennedy & Menadue?
D6 Wagner or DBJ?

I am loopholing Petracca into Hewitt via Oliver

tor01doc

Quote from: Hazza09 on April 29, 2016, 12:27:13 PM
F6 spot between Tippa, B Kennedy & Menadue?
D6 Wagner or DBJ?

I am loopholing Petracca into Hewitt via Oliver

Hazza no see?

I'll show you mine (opinion) if you show me yours (opinion)  :P

Jimmykidd

Quote from: tor01doc on April 29, 2016, 11:38:31 AM
Quote from: Jimmykidd on April 29, 2016, 11:21:02 AM
mccarthy at home? paps against lions away? kennedy vs saints at etihad?

impossible  ;D

Paps > McCarthy > Kennedy but impossible really.

Dea or Hartley?

Thanks

impossible haha :P but i think dea

tor01doc


no eye deer


tor01doc

Yes. I thought about you. ha ha